Justice to the Dreaming vs. Awake

Jillian Holley

At the end of Book V of Plato’s Republic, Socrates enters a line of reasoning with Glaucon that is trying to qualify the love of wisdom that the philosopher king must possess by comparing the necessary viewpoint to those of the falsely enlightened people who appreciate beauty only in its material or tangible forms. By posing this question of how beauty should be perceived, as the imperfect and material or perfect and theoretical, Socrates shows that the man who is awake “believes in the beautiful itself [and] can see both it and the things that participate in it,” as opposed to the man in a dream world who “believes in beautiful things but doesn’t believe in the beautiful itself” (476c,d). He is equating the ability to conceptualize something that cannot be definitely seen or known to the defining skill of those who are to be deemed knowledgeable, which creates questions about how this development relates to the established characteristics of the envisioned city of Kallipolis and concepts of justice proposed in response to Socrates throughout Republic.

Firstly, does this explanation of knowledge support or contradict how Socrates views justice in this society? At the end of Book IV, Socrates made clear the necessity of the rules of Justice found in the soul that is ruled by the “inner harmony” (443e) between its three distinct facets. If this inner harmony is completely necessary within every member of society since justice is the hinge by which the city functions, and the city is little more than the sum of its parts, the sparsity of knowledgeable and introspective actors within Kallipolis would not be able to maintain Socrates’s concept of justice. The citizens, consisting mainly of the people in the state of “dreaming… [thinking] that a likeness is not a likeness but rather the thing itself that is like,” would be blind to justice without realizing its true form as separate from the perceivable justice around them (476d). This form of justice, readily available to the dreaming majority, must then only be visible in the form of the actions of fellow citizens or the words philosopher kings who, to no avail, describe the essence of beauty to these opines who cannot conceptualize its truest form. This essential contradiction is where I see Socrates’s overarching concern with justice to falter because he describes a city in which all individuals must be internally just, yet sees the greater part of them as not having the depth of understanding necessary to produce justice in its proper and true form.

By discrediting the way that this portion of his city thinks about and performs justice, Socrates also seems to inadvertently be contradicting his claim that proper education of virtue is the solution to create just souls within his city, which now calls into question his definition of justice entirely. What is justice in the context of Republic if it is not consistent with the aforementioned concept of inner harmony or the education system designed primarily with its production in mind? With these contradictions, it could be argued that, by adding this disjunction between the wisdom of the philosopher king and that of the common people, Socrates is to some degree confirming the proposition from Book II that justice is mainly performative as it is seen through Glaucon’s telling of the Ring of Gyges. In telling this myth, Glaucon questions whether being internally just is actually beneficial, or if most people perform just acts for the sake of the perceptions of those around them. Since the dreaming man must look to others for a basis upon which to act justly since he has no concept of the essence of justice itself, mustn’t he be conforming to the concept of justice proposed in the Ring of Gyges? Seeing that the only way the opines can know justice is through observing the actions of their peers and not through an innate tendency to act justly, they all must be mimicking justice in its tangible form, making Socrates’s reasoning for widespread internal justice eternally at odds with his description of the general public.

Jillian’s Writer Bio

Hometown: St. Albans, West Virginia.

(Intended) Major: Political Science.

License

Share This Book