To be Free is to be Yourself: How Authentic Selfhood leads to Humility and Selflessness
Maximilian Binns Stein
The Apology by Plato is a classic of Western philosophy that demonstrates the transcendental value of philosophy. While people tend to think of philosophy as incredibly abstract with very few practical applications, The Apology is a clear counterexample to this trope and it is simply striking just how pragmatic Scorates’ abstractions are. However, this pragmatism is not a ‘worldy’ one, but rather a truly transcendental, spiritual pragmatism that does not necessarily help one achieve worldly success, but brings one to the fullness of their own humanity. To be more precise, Socrates speaks of “The Good Life,” a life which requires true freedom, which causes one to know oneself truly, which brings about humility through assurance and peace.
Socrates exemplifies freedom in the classical sense in The Apology. Socrates is brought to trial before the men of Athens where he stands accused of corrupting the youth (Plato, et al. 36). However, even though this accusation is false because all Socrates has done is open the minds of the young, he does not deny this accusation and accepts it for he knows that what the men of Athens think of as ‘corruption,’ is really just liberation. Relatedly, Socrates’ resolve in front of the jurors comes from this liberation that Socrates has attained and has dispensed to youth, in a very aptly, free way. This liberation, however, is not detached from any sense of the Good, but rather the freedom that comes from conforming oneself to the Good, which, for Socrates, is the divine voice, which he has encountered. This is the classical notion of freedom and Socrates’ fidelity to the god, which is the avenue through which he has this freedom, is very clearly displayed in one particular quote: “Be sure that this is what the god orders me to do, and I think there is no greater blessing for the city than my service to the god” (Plato, et al. 33). Here, there is a beautiful connection that can be made to the work of the great nineteenth century Catholic theologian St. John Henry Cardinal Newman. Cardinal Newman’s seminal contributions to Christian accounts of the conscience can be succinctly put with his beautiful line that “the conscience is the abirigional vicar of Christ, in the soul,” (Seward, 2019). For Cardinal Newman, even if one does not have explicit knowledge of Christ, they are true followers of Him if they conform to their conscience: if they conform, in other words, to the Good. I would like to argue, then, that Socrates encounters Christ when he encounters the “low voiced god” dwelling within his interiority, and that his obedience to the god equals true freedom, for the god which Socrates encounters is the Good. Since Socrates encounters the divine Good, and conforms to it, as demonstrated in the quote above, he is truly free.
The freedom that Socrates possesses enables him to have a knowledge of his true self. Freedom as conformity to the Good is the classical understanding of freedom, and it has its roots in the ontology of the Good, which is identical to being, and so evil is merely a privation or distortion of the Good in some way; evils limit or bind the Good. Relating this to freedom, on the classical understanding to be in conformity to the Good is to be truly free because one has come to the fullness of their being, and has shaken off, so to speak, any limits that they had on their being. Freedom cannot be intelligible except in relation to the Good because such “freedom” makes no reference to ontology, and may lead to one tending towards non-being, which is clearly the opposite to freedom. When reflecting on his own path towards true freedom, the great spiritual master Thomas Merton said: “For me to be a saint means to be myself” (Merton 31). Merton understood that when he sins, in a very real ontological sense, he is not himself as he is tending towards non-being, which also means that he is not truly free when he sins. Therefore, when Merton acts in conformity with the Good, he is truly free, but also truly himself as since the Good and being are identical, when one conforms to the Good, one truly and most fully exists. There is a conceptually intermediate step, though, between true freedom and being one’s true self and that is self-knowledge through the process of self-reflection or, as Merton calls it “prayer”. Merton has a very Thomistic analysis of prayer where prayer is the space in which one becomes aware of how, here and now, one is being created by God (Barron). Therefore, for Merton, prayer is a necessary step in one’s journey towards oneself for it enables one to know who God is creating: it enables them to know who they are. The reason that prayer is a merely conceptual step between true freedom and true selfhood is because being one’s true self and being truly free are, in actuality, the same thing, but they are conceptually distinct because true freedom enables knowledge of one’s true self. Relating this to Socrates, since he has encountered the divine, the Good, in himself and conformed himself to the god, he is truly free and through this freedom and self-reflection he comes to know himself as himself.
Socrates’ perfect self-knowledge, through the assurance that it naturally elicits, is what grounds Socrates’ humility before the people of Athens. The knowledge of himself that Socrates possesses does not lead to self-centeredness or pride because the satisfaction that accompanies Socrates’ knowledge of his true self is perfect satisfaction. Perfect satisfaction leaves nothing to be wanted, and enables Socrates to be detached from the world, which, paradoxically, enables Socrates to liberate others. This teaching and guiding labor is exactly the “crime” he is accused of having “committed.”
This knowledge, therefore, in conjunction with perfect satisfaction brings about a peaceful humility, where humility is self-lessness, for the one who knows themselves so fully, are also completely satisfied. This is why Socrates is fearless in front of the jury: he is truly free because of his loyalty to the god, the Good, which gives him a knowledge of his true self which then causes his humility through the satisfaction that comes about from such self-knowledge. This is why Socrates can stand before the men of Athens and say: “It would be a fine life at my age to be driven out of one city after another, for I know very well that wherever I go the young men will listen to my talk as they do here” (Plato, et al. 39). He is detached from the world: he is truly free.
Plato’s Apology is a beautiful example of the transformative power of philosophy. Plato is able to recount in a short narrative span the startling and striking behavior of a truly free man. Socrates is a man who is detached because of his perfect freedom and perfect self-knowledge. He is a man who has come to the fullness of himself and through this he ‘diffuses’ himself to the youth of Athens. Socrates is humble, he is self-less, because he is free: he has conformed to the Good. This is why he is managing to be himself, his true self, before the men of Athens: ontologically, he could not be anything else.
Works Cited
Barron, Robert. Bishop Barron on Thomas Merton, Spiritual Master – Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5X8fp2CvQmA.
Merton, Thomas. New Seeds of Contemplation. New Directions Book, 2007.
Plato, et al. The Trial and Death of Socrates: Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Death Scene from Phaedo. Hackett, 2009.
Seward, Daniel. “How Newman Followed His Conscience, No Matter the Cost.” Saint John Henry, Saint John Henry, 28 Aug. 2019, https://www.newmancanonisation.com/blog/newmanandconscience#:~:text=Conscience%2%E2%80%93%20the%20%27aboriginal%20vicar%20of,mean%20%E2%80%9Chow%20I%20feel%E2%80%9D.
Maximilian’s Writer Bio
Hometown: New York City.
(Intended) Major: Philosophy.
Favorite Author/Book: My favorite novel is The Heart of the Matter by Graham Greene.
Preferred Writing Mode: Philosophical expression.
On-campus Writing Spot: I most enjoy writing in Axinn.
Best Writing Feedback Received: The best writing feedback I’ve ever received is to slow down. I had a tendency, and to a lesser extent still do, to speed through my essays in high school. The satisfaction of simply completing the assignment was often more important to me than attending to the work with care. In tenth grade, my english teacher advised me to slow down and to be more attentive to my writing. Following his advice immensely improved my writing, but also deepened my understanding of its power and beauty.
Advice for Fellow Writers: I would advise my fellow writers to write as much as possible. This has the pragmatic benefit of improving your writing, but more importantly providing you with an outlet to reflect and engage with yourself and the world. Such reflection and engagement changes you and helps to form you into who you are, which is infinitely valuable in itself.