Communism and Consciousness in the Time of Capital or, Shooting Oneself in the Foot
Thomas Summers
Karl Marx is the ultimate enlightenment thinker. Sprung from the head of the scientific revolution, the enlightenment prioritized rationalism and secularism. It sought freedom from feudalism, and its political philosophers – Smith, Locke, Rosseau – promised liberty. As time passed, palaces turned into museums and parliaments replaced kings. Most importantly, as far as Marx is concerned, the feudal systems of serfdom and the nobility were replaced by markets and the bourgeoisie. Here, Marx turns on his predecessors. For Marx, liberal capitalism isn’t enough. The dream of the enlightenment was liberation – not capital. Marx develops a famous, original analysis of capitalism and predicts a future state: communism. However, Marx develops a dialectic of economics. This means that capitalism is just a stepping stone towards communism. This analysis forces him to forgo morality and to accept capitalism as fundamentally flawed but crucial. Marx therefore attacks and defends capitalism – both capitalism’s critic and champion. How can he hold these contradictory positions? Marx believes all of the abuses of capitalism are necessary to reach communism, meaning he must defend capitalism while also trying to abolish it.
First, one must know how capitalism is developed. This can be tricky. Marx never developed a systematic theory of history; in many writings he preferred to presuppose capitalism and move from there. For Marx, capitalism directly proceeds from the previous system: Feudalism. However, man is not a feudal animal. The first scheme of human organization is the tribe, where the chief holds power. These tribes unite into early cities, similar to classical civilizations like Greece and Rome. However, the classical cities don’t directly develop into modern cities. In the classical cities, power “started out from the town and the small territory around it; the Middle Ages started out from the country” (109). Communism could not proceed from classical civilization because the proto-proletariat was in between the “propertied citizens and slaves” (109). It remained small, had little productive power, and was never in direct opposition to the “ancient community” (109). As Rome fell, sacked by barbarians, a new society developed in the image of the “Germanic Military Constitution” (110). Serfs now stood as the direct producing class, finally opposing the nobles. After centuries of depredations and oppression, serfs began to flee to towns, where the power of guilds increased and productive forces concentrated. Finally, Feudalism is reached. Division of labor, a hallmark of capitalism, is “very little” (110). The towns are aligned against the country, the seat of the Nobles.
Marx leaves his analysis here, but it’s simple to infer the next steps. Marx analyzes modes of production in terms of power: which class is using what power to dominate the productive class. The towns continue to grow in power as new technology concentrates productive forces. Nobles become increasingly irrelevant as the towns turn to cities and the guild leaders gain clout and power, seizing the reins of government. The “most heavenly ecstasies of religious fervour, of chivalrous enthusiasm, of philistine sentimentalism” are drowned “in the icy water of egotistical calculation” (299). Parliaments rise. The Bourgeoisie are born. The conflicts between the productive class and the political community are raised to new levels, and the opportunity to transcend the conflict is nigh.
Marx’s analysis of human history and class stages is called historical materialism. The phrase “We know only one science, the science of history” (107) begins The German Ideology. Historical materialism – Marx’s theory of the stages of human societies – isn’t called such until Socialism: Utopian and Scientific by Engles. However, it’s clearly expressed in The German Ideology with the phrase “Consciousness does not determine life, but life determines consciousness” (112). In other words, it is the material conditions of an era that determines men’s mode of social and political life which in turn determines their consciousness. Marx disagrees with thinkers, like Adam Smith or John Locke, who might say that man has a fixed nature which remains the same despite the circumstances. The classic Hegelian dialectic refines material conditions, showing that one can analyze opposing forces and find one clear solution while retaining the essence. Marx runs the process exactly backwards. Consciousness is not an ephemeral concept that determines how men live their lives. Rather, consciousness is a thought that thinks itself independent when in fact it is incredibly dependent on the modes and manners that men live. As Nietszche might put it: God did not make man, Man made god.
Marx is no champion of capitalism. He critiques the system constantly throughout his writings. The bourgeoisie commit “naked, shameless, direct, brutal exploitation” (161). Doctors, priests, and poets all become capitalists, “paid wage-laborers” (161), and shills. “The bourgeoisie has torn away from the family its sentimental veil” (161). The new and brutal system of capitalism tears away all feudal illusions. The proletarian, previously advantaged as an artisan or skilled labor, is so reduced by the dehumanization and alienation of the division of labor that he no longer has anything to lose. Creators of this situation, “the bourgeoisie (has) forged the weapons that bring death to itself” (164). Under the new material conditions, ideas like honor and chivalry are irrelevant and die. At last, “man is … compelled to face with sober senses, his real conditions of life, and his relations with his kind” (162). Capitalism stands naked in the cold. The real ideas and the real power dynamics, previously obscured in ancient states by ideology, are finally plain enough for all to see. However, Marx is more nuanced than he first seems.
Marx doesn’t moralize as much as some think. Marx never calls the bourgeoise evil. Nor, in fact, does he ever call the proletariat especially good. Parts of The Communist Manifesto do remind readers of epic good vs. evil narratives, but this is more due to Marx’s stylistic choices rather than his arguments. Someone like Nietszche would describe history as a struggle between the good and the evil; Marx doesn’t do that. As much as “criticizes” the ruling class in one breath, as he describes the “heavenly ecstasy” and “chivalrous enthusiasm” (299) destroyed by the bourgeoisie, Marx “praises” the bourgeoisie in one another, describing how “ It has accomplished wonders far surpassing Egyptian pyramids, Roman aqueducts, and Gothic cathedrals” (161). In fact, Marx needs capitalism to reach his ideal state. He describes a scientific process leading to communism. Capitalism is the only way to both sufficiently empower the proletariat and deprive it enough so it will revolt. Marx doesn’t moralize because he can’t moralize. Marx’s framework forces him to either remain neutral or support clear abuses of capitalism.
Marx supports much of what the bourgeoisie are doing and he cannot really criticize even some clear moral excesses of the bourgeoisie. The tycoon that chooses to underpay and starve his workers isn’t just a faceless part of a mass power structure. He’s also a person, making conscious choices to harm others for greed. Marx, through his style, suggests that he recognizes this. However, Marx cannot call for someone to stop the tycoon. Marx’s theory requires that the tycoon underpay his workers. Otherwise, the workers will feel no need to rise up in revolt. Marx cannot call for reform of existing systems. He must advocate for wholesale reconstruction of society. Through his style, he obscures this fact. For example: When Marx says that the bourgeoisie have made the “all that is holy … profaned” (162), his style gives the wrong initial impression. Profaning is usually a bad thing; Marx thereby suggests that he opposes the bourgeoisie. However, Marx himself wants the holy to be profaned. In Towards a Critique of Hegel’s “Philosophy of Right”, Marx calls religion the “opium of the people”. Perhaps this is because The Communist Manifesto was for a mass audience, while his other works were often unpublished and much more academic. Marx’s style obscures his true position: not as a partisan in the war between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie, but as a theorist predicting the outcome.
Marx is neither a critic nor champion of capitalism: Marx views capitalism as a sacrifice made so humanity can reach a higher stage. This is clear in his commentary on the British rule in India under the East India Trading Company. Marx says “:..can mankind fulfil its destiny without a fundamental revolution in the social state of Asia? If not, whatever may have been the crimes of England she was the unconscious tool of history in bringing about that revolution.” (The British Rule in India). Marx says this despite the atrocities committed by the British empire, the “brutal interference of the British tax-gatherer and the British soldier”. Marx is only tangentially sympathetic to the Indian cause. The murder and pillage of Indians and Indian society, “sickening as it must be to human feeling” (The British Rule in India), is nonetheless necessary to break “Oriental despotism” (The British Rule in India) and stop the “degradation” of the human prostrating himself before the sacred cow. The suffering and cries of the colonized must happen, says Marx. No matter how morally evil the actions of the empire are, colonialism is necessary to put India on the path to communism. Many of Marx’s other critiques are similar. Even the “naked, shameless, direct, brutal exploitation” (161) of the proletariat is necessary: without it, the proletariat would never overthrow the bourgeoisie. Other ideas, like honor and chivalry, must be destroyed to reach Marx’s destination. Communism is built on struggle, but in the case of Marx’s views on India this struggle feels much more concrete than his abstract descriptions in The German Ideology.
Francis Bacon, a key figure in the European enlightenment, published his seminal work on the scientific method Novum Organum in 1620. A year before, the first African slaves in the U.S. had arrived in Jamestown, Virginia. This contradiction – a society championing freedom and enlightenment for all built on the enslavement and colonialism of the other – is intrinsic to the enlightenment. Marx, the ultimate enlightenment thinker, is no different. Marx’s grand theory ties him into the issues and mores of his own time. Marx saw a capitalism dependent on colonialism, exploitation, slavery, and pillage. He rightly believed conditions could and should be improved. But rather than envision a better capitalism, he envisioned an entirely new movement. Unfortunately, the scale and hubris of this project overcame him: Marx could not lift himself out of his vantage point.
Marx internalizes the evils of capitalism into his theory, making greed and depredations necessary to fulfill his predictions. Marx cannot advocate for incremental reform. Any movement that concretely helps people – a graduated income tax, higher wages, social democracy – in fact takes people further away from communism by making their situation less desperate. Marx cannot criticize what is undeniably evil: neither the robber barons who subjected millions of workers to unbearable conditions to satisfy their own greed nor the monarchs who enriched themselves by crushing the customs and spirit of weaker countries. Ironically, there were few harsher critics of colonialism than Adam Smith, who wrote “Great Britain should voluntarily give up all authority over her colonies, and leave them to elect their own magistrates, to enact their laws, and to make peace and war as they might think proper’ (The Wealth of Nations, 616). Smith had the restraint and humility to look for what is immediately best and just. Marx didn’t.
Thomas’ Writer Bio
Hometown: Seattle, Houston.
(Intended) Majors: Classics & Political Science.
Favorite Author/Book: Absalom, Absalom by William Faulkner.
Preferred Writing Mode: Fiction.
On-campus Writing Spot: Abernathy Room.
Best Writing Feedback Received: Omit needless words.
Advice for Fellow Writers: Read “Politics and the English Language” by Orwell.