The Experience of the Black Condition: Black Pain & Joy Through Art
Casandra Dormeus
Art transcends many emotions, ranging from lust and longing to hatred and anger. It is used as a medium to express feelings, tell stories and connect the artist to the viewer. Black art specifically, becomes an embodiment of something greater. It translates pain, joy, desire and a large array of other emotions that are attached to the Black being. Sadly, there is a distinction between White pain and White joy, and Black pain and Black joy. While White artists also use art to express their emotions and tell their stories, it doesn’t bear as much significance as Black artists using their art to express their emotions and tell their stories. Black people are a marginalized group that have had nearly everything taken from them, appropriated or gentrified. Hairstyles, nail art, piercings, waist beads, slang and many other artifacts that hold a significance to the Black community have been taken away from us in some way, shape or form.
The concepts of Black pain and Black joy may seem foreign to many, as those who are not Black have not experienced it. Black pain is the realization that you are a part of a society that disregards your very being. It is “the psychological and the physiological costs of moving through a society in which, at any given moment, you may be unseen/invisible, or mis-seen as an imminent physical threat, or viewed as a spectacle of abjection” (Dobbs 168). Living in a society where your suffering often goes unheard as you fade into the background, or as you stick out like a sore thumb, but everyone is too scared to acknowledge your very being.
Too scared to acknowledge your pain, or their participation in the active reinforcement of your pain.
Too scared to acknowledge your Blackness, or to even say the word Black. Whispering it and cautiously saying it, as if their tongue will rot and fall off. Saying it with utter caution, as if they will turn Black too, if they say the word.
Black joy on the other hand, is very different from Black pain. Black joy is choosing to be happy in the face of adversity. It is choosing to acknowledge or even ignore the fact that you are living in a society that is built on the back of your very people, yet gives you no credit for your contributions. Black joy is choosing to be happy in your own skin and rejoice in your Blackness.
I’m Black and I’m proud.
Through their art, Black artists convey the concepts of Black pain and Black joy in ways unique to the artist’s style. In Claudia Rankine’s Citizen, she introduces the concepts of Black pain and Black joy through lived experiences told from a second perspective. Rankine experiments with storytelling, as she conveys the concepts of Black pain and Black joy through experiences that many Black people can relate to. Black artists convey the concept of Black pain and Black joy through lived experiences, as Rankine has demonstrated throughout Citizen. Rankine mentions Hennessy Youngman, an artist who expresses his Art Thoughtz through youtube tutorials. Youngman has a video where he talks about Black pain and the marketability of it. “He advises Black artists to cultivate an ‘angry nigger exterior’ by watching, among other things, the Rodney King video while working” (Rankine 27). The concept of Black pain comes about, as Youngman expresses to Black artists, the need to cultivate “an angry nigger exterior”. The real question comes about: Why does Black pain and Black anger need to go hand in hand? Is it not possible to have one without the other? Why must Black people tap into their traumas, such as watching their own brother, Rodney King, being beaten in order to create art that is fueled by their pain? Rankine refers to what Youngman is talking about as “commodified anger” that is “…tied solely to the performance of Blackness and not to the emotional state of particular individuals…” in relation to Black pain and how Black artists present it (Rankine 27-28). Through Youngman’s method particularly, he sees Black pain as a commodity, something that can be profited off of. In a way, I can see where Youngman comes from and why he sees Black pain as a commodity. For instance, some White people have a White Savior Complex. A complex in which they wish to rush in and ‘save’ Black people from their pain, as a way to compensate for their guilt as a White person and the role that they play in racism and systemic oppression. Due to this complex, many White people play a certain role when interacting with Black people. They see them as charity cases and feel that they need to do all that they can to affirm Black people’s presence, and make them feel like they matter. This is played out in many different ways, but in the Youngman’s case, many White people may buy art that is filled with or fueled by Black pain. They may feel as if buying/supporting this artwork is their way of supporting Black artists. Some may even call artistic pieces surrounding Black art, “so raw” and “real”, as I’ve heard several times about my poetry as a Black woman.
Amiri Baraka wrote a poem surrounding the topic of Black art, entitled “Black Art”. Baraka’s poem touches on both Black joy and Black pain, but more importantly talks about the desire for something to belong solely to Black people. In the final six lines of his poem Baraka states, “We want a Black poem. And a / Black World. / Let the world be a Black poem/ And Let All Black People Speak This Poem/ Silently/ Or LOUD” (Baraka, lines 54-55). Baraka’s longing for there to be something that belongs to Black people, so that they feel a sense of ownership comes about. Circling back to Youngman’s commodification of Black pain, Rankine mentions that Youngman previously made a video about how to be a successful artist. “While putting forward the argument that one needs to be white to be truly successful, he adds, in an aside, that this might not work for blacks because ‘if a nigger paints a flower it becomes a slavery flower, flower de Amistad’ thereby intimating that any relationship between the black viewer and the black artist immediately becomes one between white persons and black property, …” (Rankine 37-38). Why is there a distinction between Black and White artists? Why does Black art have to be traced back to or rooted in slavery? Why can it not simply exist as art? Why can it not simply stand as art by a Black artist?
Black joy is an active resistance to the systems that exist to oppress Black people. In an effort to fully understand Black joy, you must understand the systems that exist that Black joy is an active resistance to. Black joy can be defined as, “…the free expression that comes from recognizing the love that our ancestors have allowed us to embody in the face of oppression” (“Black (Gifted) Joy” 7). Why does Black joy have to once again be rooted in an active act of resistance to systemic oppression and racism? Why is it that Black people cannot simply exist in their emotions, without it being dated back to their oppression? Many artistic pieces from Black artists in relation to Black joy are centered around this very idea. The idea that they are celebrating their life, their existence and the fact that they can thrive in a system that was not built for them. In Pages Matam’s poem “Black Joy, Uninterrupted”, he speaks intimately about his Black joy. “This is not respectable/ It will not pick its pants up/ It will not turn down the music/ This will not hide because/ This is my Black joy, uninterrupted” (Matam). Matam exemplifies Black joy in these lines, as he talks about his resistance to systems of oppression. By choosing not to pick his sagging pants up, blasting his music loudly and not hiding, Matam exemplifies Black joy. Rankine shows how Black joy can be exemplified as well, while talking about Serena Williams. Serena Williams, a Black female tennis player, finds joy in simply doing her best. “When asked if she is confident she can win her upcoming matches, her answer remains, ‘At the end of the day, I am very happy with me and I am happy with my results’” (Rankine 38). Rankine’s demonstration of Black joy through Serena Williams is not tied to the established definition of Black joy. But rather, it’s simply Serena Williams, a Black woman, being happy and content with herself. An exemplification of Black joy that I believe should be the standard. Black people simply existing and being happy with themselves, not happy because they are actively resisting a system that was built to oppress them and hold them down.
Claudine Rankine’s Citizen actively exemplifies Black artists’ work in how the concepts of Black pain and Black joy are portrayed. In Citizen, Rankine talks about how the Black being and condition is a state of mourning. Rankine talks about violence against Black bodies, through physically aggressive, non-physical aggression and microaggressions. Rankine incorporates the reader as a part of the narrative, as Cantero-Sánchez explains. “The hybrid lyric depicts situations where being black stands for being stopped, checked, arrested and eligible for gun violence. In several poems the poetic ‘you’ explains how, in the encounter with the other, violence happens because black bodies are read as dangerous and as violent perpetrators, and thus, policeable” (Cantero-Sánchez, 86). Rankine’s text forces readers to become a part of the Black experience, as she speaks in the second person. Engaging the reader and forcing them to become a part of the racial other. In this passage, Rankine forces the reader to establish themself as Black and the friend in this situation as White.
“A friend tells you he has seen a photograph of you on the Internet and he wants to know why you look so angry. You and the photographer chose the photograph he refers to because you both decided it looked the most relaxed. Do you look angry? You wouldn’t have said so. Obviously this unsmiling image of you makes him uncomfortable, and he needs you to account for that. If you were smiling, what would that tell him about your composure in his imagination?” (Rankine 49).
By forcing the reader to become a part of the “you” Rankine forces the reader to identify themselves as Black, or the racial other. The person that is now talking to the reader, becomes known as the oppressor. The ambiguity of Rankine’s text leaves the reader to create the connections on their own.
Citizen forces readers to look deeper into what Black pain truly is, through the text’s combination of words and artwork. Rankine puts the reader in the position to be a Black being. She forces them to truly live the life of a Black person, particularly through the instance of breathing.

Rankine speaks closely on the Black body in relation to breathing. “The sigh is the pathway to breath; it allows breathing. That’s just self-preservation. No one fabricates that” (Rankine 61). Rankine talks about the politicization of breathing in Black bodies through her art. She is ambiguous enough in her story telling to leave the reader to connect the dots, wondering how the lines can be drawn to the Black experience.
Rankine’s experimental text Citizen provokes readers to immerse themselves into the idea of becoming the racial other. Rankine introduces the concepts of Black pain and Black joy through the many scenarios she poses throughout the text. She forces the reader to become uncomfortable and force labels onto people’s race throughout her scenarios. The Black experience is not a monolithic one. It is a collective experience, but not every single Black person experiences the same traumas and joys as the other. Black artists have expressed that through their works, showing their own unique experiences as a Black being, through the Black condition. Black artists convey the concepts of Black pain and Black joy in their own ways. Some of them display this through anger, trying to make a profit off of it, while others express it through solemnity. Some Black artists try to play to the angry Black person stereotype, while others try to break free of that role. Art conveys many emotions and it can be perceived differently based on many factors in relation to it. Black art, being the embodiment of something bigger than the artist themselves. It becomes tied to slavery, resistance and systemic oppression. Black joy is a symbol of actively resisting the system that tries to hold back Black people and make them unhappy. It is the embodiment of systemic racism and oppression, yet rejecting it to be happy with yourself. Black pain is the symbol of acknowledging the pain and oppression that you have been through. It is carrying that pain and openly singing the woes of it. Black art in itself is a resistance to systemic oppression and racism, as we sing our personal tales and truths.

Bibliography
- “Black (Gifted) Joy: A Critical Race Theory Perspective.” Investment Weekly News, 27 Feb. 2021. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=edsgbe&AN=edsgcl.652539944&site=eds-live&scope=site.
- ButtonPoetry. “Pages Matam – Black Joy, Uninterrupted.” YouTube, YouTube, 9 Feb. 2017, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0FsV3ocBOJ8.
- Cantero-Sánchez, M. “On Racism and the Impossibility of Mourning: A Critical Reading of Claudia Rankine’s Citizen, an American Lyric.” Revista de Estudios Norteamericanos, vol. 2018, no. 22, pp. 83–101. EBSCOhost, doi:10.12795/REN.2018.i22.04. Accessed 1 Dec. 2021.
- Dobbs, Cynthia. “Diagnosis Race: Troubling Etiologies in Claudia Rankine’s American Lyrics.” Literature and Medicine, vol. 38 no. 1, 2020, p. 168-188. Project MUSE, doi:10.1353/lm.2020.0007.
- Rankine, Claudia. Citizen. An American Lyric. Minneapolis, MN: Graywolf, 2014. Print.
Casandra’s Writer Bio
Hometown: Jamaica, New York.
(Intended) Majors: Educations Studies & English.
Favorite Author/Book: said the shotgun to the head by Saul Williams.
Preferred Writing Mode: Poetry.
On-campus Writing Spot: I’ve found that some of my best pieces are born in the cubicles of Davis Library.
Advice for Fellow Writers: For my fellow Middlebury writers, Allow yourself to write freely. Do not worry about grammatical errors or the mechanics of writing. Writing in academia is so often stiffened and restricted, so I encourage you all to begin to think outside the box with your writing. Rather than thinking of what to write, let the words find their way through you. Writers are merely facilitators in the discussion between the paper and words. With due time, the words will find their way through you and adorn your paper. Allow the words to do the work, as you adorn the paper with words, bringing the discussion between the two together.
Anything to Share: This particular essay was written after an extremely rough first semester for me. I was experiencing imposter syndrome and it was truly getting me down, as I tried to navigate being a woman of color at a predominantly white institution, in a predominantly white state. I’ve always found comfort in prose, but was seldom allowed to incorporate it into my writing assignments this first semester. When given the chance to incorporate it into an academic essay, I ran with it. This was my first time ever playing with space and structure and I was extremely proud of the final product. I’ve always imagined possibly creating a video with a voiceover of the reading of this essay! One thing I hope readers take away from this essay is that being Black is not a monolithic experience. Black people as a collective do not have one common experience and it is important to acknowledge that when reading work like this. In addition to that, it is not the responsibilities of Black people to actively speak out and educate others on issues that disproportionately affect Black people. Take the time to “do the work” and educate yourself on issues that disproportionately impact BIPOC folks.