Evaluating Academic Integrity in Historical Research: A Case Study
Yashodar Sharma
J. Mark Ramseyer, the Mitsubishi Professor of Japanese Legal Studies at Harvard University, was widely criticised by other academics for his article, Contracting for Sex in the Pacific War, in part due to the lack of academic integrity displayed by the work. It is clear that Ramseyer failed to adhere to several key principles of academic integrity, as he did not indicate his own bias, did not acknowledge the limitations of his evidence (and, in some cases, provided no evidence), and used existing evidence in bad faith. These three principles are key in the creation of academic writing. I believe them to be reasonable, as it is fair to expect that a piece of writing does not mislead a reader.
Firstly, it is important that a writer acknowledge their own biases clearly, so readers are able to receive the work with the correct context. In this case, Ramseyer did not indicate his apparent belief that the “comfort women” controversy is baseless, potentially misleading a reader into believing his work to be objective. His official title at Harvard University is “Mitsubishi Professor of Japanese Studies”[1], which may in itself indicate a bias; Mitsubishi, like several other old industrial conglomerates, has a somewhat chequered history when it comes to war[2], and, as such, would have a vested interest in denying the atrocities committed during Japan’s violent expansion in the 1930s and ‘40s. More importantly, Ramseyer later published a piece entitled Recovering the Truth about the Comfort Women in Japan Forward, a “news/opinion site
doi:10.1080/10371390600986702. established by the neo-nationalist Japanese Sankei Media group to propagate its views and those of likeminded [sic] people to an English-speaking audience”, that is currently running a “very energetic campaign […] aimed at denying that any ‘comfort women’ […] were recruited by force and deception and denouncing women who testify to forcible recruitment as liars”[3]. In this piece, Ramseyer’s tone shifted from a more “academically-worded” conclusion to a more “aggressively political statement that ‘the comfort-women-sex-slave theory’ is ‘pure fiction’”[4]. While there is clear evidence to show that Ramseyer may have had a motive for writing this paper, he made none of it clear to readers, which could cause them to believe that his perspective is objective and the paper’s motive is purely informational.
Another important principle of academic integrity is providing evidence and acknowledging its limits. Ramseyer’s work failed to adhere to this principle in places. Tessa Morris-Suzuki, professor emeritus at the Australian National University notes that he “provides no evidence that he has ever seen such a contract, and no oral or written testimony from anyone who had ever signed one of these contracts or witnessed one being signed”[5], referring to the contracts Ramseyer said the comfort women signed. In fact, Ramseyer was well aware that evidence to support his point of contracts being signed may not exist at all; according Hijoo Son’s article Undeniable: The Lived Experience of the “Comfort Women”, Ramseyer says “I haven’t been able to find it. Certainly, you’re not going to find it”[6]. Stanley et al.’s case for the retraction of Ramseyer’s article concurs with the above two, stating that Ramseyer “produces no evidence of any signed contracts for work at “comfort stations,” whether for Japanese, Korean,
or any other women”[7]. The message of the three sources is clear: evidence of signed contracts (which could be used to support Ramseyer’s argument) does not exist, and his argument is therefore baseless. The lack of evidence was not the only issue, however; some of the “evidence” used by Ramseyer has major limitations that he did not acknowledge. Jeannie Suk Gersen quotes Morris-Suzuki letter to the International Review of Law and Economics, which said that Ramseyer “transposes” evidence from a study that focused on Japan in the 1920s and early 1930s[8]. Extrapolating from this evidence may, under certain circumstances, be considered acceptable; however, Ramseyer did this without acknowledging the fact that his evidence was relevant to a “drastically different” time, place, and set of circumstances[9]. In another case, Ramseyer provided evidence of a 10-year-old girl who was offered money to go abroad, saying “even at age 10, she knew what the job entailed”[10]. This flies in the face of common sense; it is unreasonable to assume that a 10-year-old would understand what it means to be a sex worker. This means that Ramseyer misled readers by not indicating his evidence’s limitations, potentially leading readers to develop misconceptions. Another feature of acknowledging the limitations of evidence is addressing (at least some) evidence to the contrary. Morris-Suzuki points out that his article “ignores testimony of cases where women clearly did not sign ‘contracts’ of any sort”[11]. This is also important, as, if a paper does not address contradictory pieces of evidence, it does not provide a complete picture of the subject matter. The above examples show that Ramseyer practically invented evidence to support a point he was attempting to make and did not acknowledge that the existing evidence had serious limitations, potentially misleading readers.
Continuing on the theme of evidence usage, Ramseyer did not use the existing evidence in good faith, often selectively quoting, or mischaracterizing sources, in order to support the point he attempted to make. For example, Ramseyer’s usage of the 10-year-old girl, Osaki (referred to in the above paragraph) as an example, mischaracterized her testimony; contrary to his claim, Osaki was deceived by the recruiters and was unhappy with the “work” she was made to do. Ramseyer carefully cut around this, focusing on her initial (pre-initiation) happiness about being able to eat white rice[12]. In another mischaracterisation, Ramseyer selectively used evidence from U.S. military sources to support his claim that the ‘comfort women’ worked on contracts. According to Stanley et al.’s article, the U.S. military interrogation revealed that some women did sign contracts; however, the source also stated that the work was “assumed to be […] consisting of visiting the wounded in hospitals, rolling bandages, and generally making the soldiers happy”[13]. Therefore, when the source is considered in its entirety, the implication is clear: contradictory to Ramseyer’s claim, the women did not sign contracts for sex work. Stanley et al.’s paper also contains several pages dedicated to incorrectly-cited evidence in Ramseyer’s work; some of the more egregious offences include citing a non-existent page in a book (“page 451 does not exist as the book is 336 pages long”), quoting sources that do not exist, and misquoting statistics from cited works[14]. These pieces of evidence clearly show the misleading nature of Ramseyer’s article, as evidence is the foundation of any argument, and Ramseyer was only able to support his argument by manipulating and inventing it.
To conclude, Ramseyer’s work, Contracting for Sex in the Pacific War, did not adhere to several principles of academic integrity. He did not indicate to the reader his biases, acknowledge
the limitations of his evidence (in some cases providing none or citing fictional evidence), or use the existing evidence in good faith. These transgressions practically amount to an abuse of power, as Ramseyer used his credentials (and the fact that the subject matter is likely unfamiliar to an English-speaking audience) to make a baseless claim in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary, potentially misleading readers. It is important to hold academic writing to this (higher) standard due to the fact that the writers are all highly qualified and it is reasonable to expect that their work is well-researched and their points well-founded, as their papers are meant to be informative, not opinionated.
Bibliography
“J. Mark Ramseyer | Harvard Law School”. Hls.Harvard.Edu, Last modified 2021.https://hls.harvard.edu/faculty/directory/10697/Ramseyer.
Gersen, J., 2021. Seeking the True Story of the Comfort Women. The New Yorker.
Morris-Suzuki, Tessa. The ‘Comfort Women’ Issue, Freedom Of Speech, And Academic Integrity: A Study Aid.
Palmer, David. “The Straits Of Dead Souls: One Man’s Investigation Into The Disappearance Of Mitsubishi Hiroshima’s Korean Forced Labourers”. Japanese Studies 26, no. 3 (2006): 335-351.doi:10.1080/10371390600986702.
Ramseyer, John Mark. “Contracting For Sex In The Pacific War”. International Review Of Law And Economics, 2020.
Son, Hijoo. “Undeniable: The Lived Experience Of The Comfort Women”. Blog. Medium, 2021.
Stanley, Amy, Hannah Shepherd, Sayaka Chatani, David Ambaras, and Chelsea Szendi Schieder. ““Contracting For Sex In The Pacific War”: The Case For Retraction On Grounds Of Academic Misconduct”. The Asia-Pacific Journal 19, no. 5 (2021)
Yashodar’s Writer Bio
Hometown: Mumbai, India.
(Intended) Majors: Economics & Psychology.
Favorite Book/Author: Either Catch-22 or Inverting the Pyramid.
Preferred Writing Mode: Anything but poetry.
On-campus Writing Spot: The Abernathy Room.
Best Writing Feedback Received: “British vs. English spellings??” on an Economics paper I wrote. I grew up learning the British (or English) variant of English and I use those spellings instead of the American ones, which seemed to confuse my classmate.
Advice for Fellow Writers: Simple, direct language is best; it’s easier to read and write.
- "J. Mark Ramseyer | Harvard Law School". Hls.Harvard.Edu, Last modified 2021.https://hls.harvard.edu/faculty/directory/10697/Ramseyer. ↵
- Palmer, David. "The Straits Of Dead Souls: One Man's Investigation Into The Disappearance Of Mitsubishi Hiroshima's Korean Forced Labourers". Japanese Studies 26, no. 3 (2006): 335-351. ↵
- Morris-Suzuki, Tessa. The ‘Comfort Women’ Issue, Freedom Of Speech, And Academic Integrity: A Study Aid, 6 ↵
- Morris Suzuki, 5 ↵
- Morris-Suzuki, 7 ↵
- Son, Hijoo. “Undeniable: The Lived Experience Of The Comfort Women”. Blog. Medium, 2021. ↵
- Stanley, Amy, Hannah Shepherd, Sayaka Chatani, David Ambaras, and Chelsea Szendi Schieder. "“Contracting For Sex In The Pacific War”: The Case For Retraction On Grounds Of Academic Misconduct". The Asia-Pacific Journal 19, no. 5 (2021): 3 ↵
- Gersen, J., 2021. Seeking the True Story of the Comfort Women. The New Yorker. ↵
- Gersen, 6 ↵
- Ramseyer, John Mark. "Contracting For Sex In The Pacific War". International Review Of Law And Economics, 2020, 4. ↵
- Morris-Suzuki, 7 ↵
- Stanley et al., 4 ↵
- Stanley et al., 10 ↵
- Stanley et al., 18-19 ↵