Research Project Plan: Outline (REVISED)

Claire Perry

TOPIC: Disability Perspectives in Urban Planning and Development

FORMAT: Conference Presentation

A conference presentation is, perhaps, the most effective way to convey my argument to an audience.  Visual aids are crucial in providing deeper understanding to disability perspectives in urban planning and development and how their role has changed over time.  Like our last digital presentation project on disability activism, a conference presentation has the potential to be accessible to everyone.  There is a lot of flexibility within this format to incorporate Universal Design practices to promote communication and accessibility.

THESIS: There has long been an absence of disability perspectives in urban planning and development.  By advocating for the use of Universal Design practices in the redesign of neighborhoods to promote walkability, neighborhoods will foster more inclusive and diverse living environments. 

Slide #1: INTRODUCTION

Promoting Diversity Through the Use of Disability Perspectives in the Redesign of Neighborhoods and Their Walkability

Slide #2: WHAT IS URBAN DESIGN?  HOW DO WE GO ABOUT UNDERSTANDING IT?

Using Linovski and Loukaitou-Sideris’ article discussing the evolution of urban design plans in North America, I will define urban design and how we may go about understanding it.  With the knowledge I have attained from this class, I would argue that urban design is crucial in understand the planning and development of neighborhoods.  In fact, Linovski and Loukaitou-Sideris argue this exact claim in narrowing the scope of urban design and arguing that urban design plans offer a window into the values of the urban design profession.[1]  By studying the evolution of urban design plans displayed in this article, we are provided insight into how a particular physical environment is conceptualized and formulated by urban designers.  While Linovksi and Loukaitou-Sideris fail to acknowledge the perspective of people with disabilities in their studies and claims, there is still validity in what they say as their article serves as just a general understanding of urban design.  Additionally, the authors propose that one way we may go about understanding urban design and what it encompasses is through the “examination of the scope, content, and goals of urban design plans.”[2]  Simply put, urban design plans can offer a “nuanced approach and guidance in regulating the quality of urban space and provide a comprehensive and accessible visual rendering of design visions.”[3]  As the social model of disability stems from society’s failure to adjust to meet the needs of people with disabilities, this article consequently lays the foundation for how we may go about changing urban design plans to be more inclusive.

Slide #3: DEFINING DISABILITY IN REGARD TO THE SOCIAL MODEL OF DISABILITY

According to the medical model of disability, the root cause of disability is health-related conditions.[4]  However, the understanding of disability has more recently strayed from the medical model and evolved toward a social model, where disabilities stem from barriers in one’s environment that serve as a barrier to accessibility and participating in social life in the community in which they live.[5]  Disability is consequently not one’s “compromised capability in navigating the environment, but rather the ‘misfit’ of capabilities between individuals and how their living environment is organized.”[6]  According to Shakespeare, the social model of disability implies that the removal of attitudinal, physical, and institutional barriers will improve the lives of people with disabilities.[7]  In other words, the responsibility is placed upon society to establish inclusivity, for when these barriers are removed, people can work toward being as independent possible and being included and equal in society.  Regarding urban planning and development, the social model promotes equity and accessibility and forces society to value the needs of people with disabilities and urban designers to take their perspectives into account when (re)designing social environments.

Slide #4: THE LACK OF DISABILITY PERSPECTIVES IN URBAN PLANNING

After understanding disability and the impact social environments have on people with disabilities in shaping their experiences and restricting their access, planning plays a crucial role in responding to these needs through changes in both built and social environments.[8]  Imrie identifies the absence or “inattentiveness” to the needs of people with disabilities in already-built neighborhoods.[9]  This essentially means that the perspectives of people with disabilities in urban design have been an “insignificant concern,” as the history of little knowledge of the needs of people with disabilities in designs and planning proves this very point.[10]  (Here, I intend to insert several examples of design flaws that pose as barriers to accessibility to people with disabilities – e.g., lack of pathways, curb cuts, poor legibility, limited and unmaintained infrastructure.[11])  Additionally, Terashima and Clark investigate the needs of people with disabilities by exploring various planning research and comparing the ways Universal Design and design-for-all can equalize opportunities and rights to space for all people.[12]  Without explicitly saying so, Terashima and Clark very clearly utilize the social model of disability to support their claims.  They seek to break down the barriers that inhibit people with disabilities from maximum participation in society in bringing their perspectives to light.

Slide #5: THE REDESIGN OF NEIGHBORHOODS TO PROMOTE WALKABILITY

By examining past studies of environment features (i.e., lack of pathways, poor legibility, limited and unmaintained infrastructure) displayed in the article by Stafford and Baldwin, it is easy to argue that they impose mobility and are thus, a result of limited Universal design.[13]  The purpose of Universal Design is to create places that any person, regardless of age and ability, can easily access.  However, it is argued that Universal Design practices have often been left out of neighborhood planning, specifically the walkability of neighborhoods.[14]  This is important because Universal Design practices and the social model of disability go hand-in-hand in creating equity and inclusion.  Using the visual example of the redesign of a neighborhood in Madison, Wisconsin, the maps demonstrate the importance of good urban design in promoting walkability and accessibility.[15]  Depicted would be before-and-after maps of “Westlawn West,” a housing project in Madison.[16]  These would provide concrete examples as to how simple changes in layout and design of neighborhoods improve walkability and accessibility.

Slide #6: CONCLUSION

With the long absence of disability perspectives in urban planning and development, it is important to begin to remove the society’s barriers to inclusivity and accessibility.  As equal members to society, urban designers must take the disability perspective into account.  Thus, advocating for the use of Universal Design practices in the redesign of neighborhoods to promote walkability, neighborhoods will foster more inclusive and diverse living environments. 

Works Cited

Adams, Rachel, et al. Keywords for Disability Studies. New York University Press, 2015. PDF.

Chu, Nancy S. “Walkability and Accessibility: Users’ Perspectives of a Planned Neighborhood.” UWM Digital Commons: Theses and Dissertations, May 2017. https://dc.uwm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2460&context=etd.

Davis, Lennard J. The Disability Studies Reader, 2013. Internet resource.

Goering, Sara. “Rethinking disability: The social model of disability and chronic disease.” Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine, Vol. 8, No. 2, 2015. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4596173/pdf/12178_2015_Article_9273.pdf.

Hamraie, Aimi. “Designing collective access: A feminist disability theory of Universal Design.” Disability Studies Quarterly, Vol. 33, No. 2, 2013. https://dsq-sds.org/article/view/3871/3411.

Imrie, Rob. “Responding to the Design Needs of Disabled People.” Journal of Urban Design, vol. 5, no. 2, Aug. 2010, pp. 199-219. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/713683959?needAccess=true.

Linovski, Orly, and Anastasia Loukaitou-Sideris. “Evolution of Urban Design Plans in the United States and Canada: What Do the Plans Tell Us about Urban Design Practice?” Journal of Planning Education and Research, vol. 33, no. 1, Aug. 2012, pp. 66-82. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0739456X12454174.

Stafford, Lisa, and Claudia Baldwin. “Planning Walkable Neighborhoods: Are We Overlooking Diversity in Abilities and Ages?” Journal of Planning Literature, vol. 33, no. 1, May 2017, pp. 17-30. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0885412217704649.

Terashima, Mikiko, and Kate Clark. “The Precarious Absence of Disability Perspectives in Planning Research.” Cogitatio, vol. 6, no. 1, Feb. 2021, pp. 120-132. https://www.cogitatiopress.com/urbanplanning/article/view/3612/3612.

Claire’s Writer Bio

Hometown: New York City.

(Intended) Major: Biology.

Favorite Author/Book: The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison.

Preferred Writing Mode: Analytical nonfiction.

On-campus Writing Spots: The Grille/Crossroads.


  1. Orly Linovski and Anastasia Loukaitou-Sid, “Evolution of Urban Design Plans in the United States and Canada: What Do the Plans Tell Us about Urban Design Practice?” (Journal of Planning Education and Research, Vol. 33, No. 1: 2012), 66.  ↵
  2. Orly Linovski and Anastasia Loukaitou-Sid, “Evolution of Urban Design Plans in the United States and Canada: What Do the Plans Tell Us about Urban Design Practice?” (Journal of Planning Education and Research, Vol. 33, No. 1: 2012), 67.  ↵
  3. Orly Linovski and Anastasia Loukaitou-Sid, “Evolution of Urban Design Plans in the United States and Canada: What Do the Plans Tell Us about Urban Design Practice?” (Journal of Planning Education and Research, Vol. 33, No. 1: 2012), 67-68. ↵
  4.   Sara Goering, “Rethinking disability: The social model of disability and chronic disease” (Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine, Vol. 8, No. 2: 2015), 134-35. ↵
  5. Mikiko Terashima and Kate Clark, “The Precarious Absence of Disability Perspectives in Planning Research” (Cogitatio, Vol. 6, No. 1: 2021), 121.  ↵
  6. Aimi Hamraie, “Designing collective access: A feminist disability theory of Universal Design” (Disability Studies Quarterly, Vol. 33, No. 2: 2013).  ↵
  7. Tom Shakespeare, “The Social Model of Disability.” In L. Davis (Ed.). The Disability Studies Reader, 2013. Internet resource, 215.  ↵
  8. Mikiko Terashima and Kate Clark, “The Precarious Absence of Disability Perspectives in Planning Research” (Cogitatio, Vol. 6, No. 1: 2021), 121.   ↵
  9. Rob Imrie, “Responding to the Design Needs of Disabled People” (Journal of Urban Design, Vol. 5, No. 2: 2010), 200.   ↵
  10. Rob Imrie, “Responding to the Design Needs of Disabled People” (Journal of Urban Design, Vol. 5, No. 2: 2010), 199-200.  ↵
  11. Lisa Stafford and Claudia Baldwin, “Planning Walkable Neighborhoods: Are We Overlooking Diversity in Abilities and Ages?” (Journal of Planning Literature, Vol. 33, No. 1: 2017), 17.  ↵
  12. Mikiko Terashima and Kate Clark, “The Precarious Absence of Disability Perspectives in Planning Research” (Cogitatio, Vol. 6, No. 1: 2021), 121-22.   ↵
  13. Lisa Stafford and Claudia Baldwin, “Planning Walkable Neighborhoods: Are We Overlooking Diversity in Abilities and Ages?” (Journal of Planning Literature, Vol. 33, No. 1: 2017), 17.  ↵
  14. Lisa Stafford and Claudia Baldwin, “Planning Walkable Neighborhoods: Are We Overlooking Diversity in Abilities and Ages?” (Journal of Planning Literature, Vol. 33, No. 1: 2017), 19.  ↵
  15. Nancy Chu, “Walkability and Accessibility: Users’ Perspectives of a Planned Neighborhood” (UWM Digital Commons: Theses and Dissertations, May 2017).  ↵
  16. Nancy Chu, “Walkability and Accessibility: Users’ Perspectives of a Planned Neighborhood” (UWM Digital Commons: Theses and Dissertations, May 2017). ↵

License

Share This Book