How has the Reading of Greek and Latin Writers Corrupted Europeans?

Gavin Richards

In Chapter 29 of Leviathan, which focuses on “those things that weaken, or tend to the dissolution of a commonwealth” (Hobbes 212), Thomas Hobbes identifies three primary attributes of Greek and Latin writing that corrupt European subjects in a monarchy: the romanticism of war, variations of language in referring to regicide, and influenced opinions on liberty.

Hobbes first establishes the tendency for young men to romanticize war and their inclination to believe writers’ persuasion. At the beginning of the passage on page 216, Hobbes mentions how these writers instill within men a “delightful impression, of the great exploits of war” (Hobbes 216-217). They “receive withal a pleasing idea” (Hobbes 217) and are inclined to engage in acts of revolt against a government, like protesting, cavalierly, not knowing the true devastation of battle and rebellion. After all, these sentiments of war directly contradict Hobbes’ second law of nature: “men are commanded to endeavour peace” (Hobbes 87). He then highlights the predisposition for young men, especially those who are “unprovided of the antidote of solid reason,” (Hobbes 216) to fall into these traps. They are too impressionable and cavalier in the face of persuasive and prolific arguments. As these young men congregate, circulating and perpetuating these sentiments of war and revolution, they pose an even bigger threat to the function of the commonwealth as a whole.

Young men persuaded by these writers not only engage in acts of war and revolution without proper concern, Hobbes goes on, but such “men have undertaken to kill their kings”(Hobbes 217) in a similarly foolish manner. Although arrogance and fallacious confidence is certainly natural in young men, the presence of these writers, and the disillusionment they create, falsely inspire them to challenge authority and commit regicide. And because, in Hobbes’ mind, the monarch is paramount to the preservation of a commonwealth, the persuasive techniques which these writers employ soon become extremely problematic.

There is an important distinction surrounding the language in referring to the killing of kings, Hobbes contends. By dubbing him a “tyrant,” (Hobbes 217) subjects are demonizing him to the public and to themselves. They are justifying their actions simply through word choice. In calling their king a tyrant, Hobbes continues, they deem this act not only lawful, but “laudable”(Hobbes 217). It has become an act of heroism rather than an act of violence. Hobbes disagrees quite vehemently. He prefers using the word “regicide,” (Hobbes 217) or the unlawful murder of a king. By inciting violence and breaking the second law of nature, these writers directly threaten the well-being of the commonwealth and entirely contradict its core values.

Hobbes, lastly, states that the opinions of monarchical subjects regarding liberty, which are influenced and exacerbated by Greek, Latin, and Roman writers, also incite disruption within a commonwealth. Hobbes contends that those who live under a monarchy believe “that the subjects in a popular commonwealth enjoy liberty; but that in a monarchy they are all slaves”(Hobbes 217). By “popular commonwealth,” Hobbes is referring to a democracy. There exists in monarchical subjects a fervent envy of democratic citizens, but Hobbes implies that this feeling is a complete fallacy removed from any sense of reality. These writers only exacerbate the unnecessary longing for liberty further. They persuade subjects into absolving themselves as so-called “slaves” and creating drastic social upheaval with no regard for how they will impact the future of the commonwealth and the good of the people as a whole. It is reckless and stupid, Hobbes reinforces throughout the passage.

Near the end of his discourse on Greek, Latin, and Roman writers, Hobbes describes the degree to which these writings can negatively impact a commonwealth and illustrates the way in which they finally dissolve a community. There is nothing “more prejudicial to a monarchy”(Hobbes 217) than these democratic writings. Hobbes even likens such pieces to venom, the biting of a mad dog, and hydrophobia, the fear of water. Although it is quite comedic, Hobbes employs the utmost urgency to this analogy. He illustrates: just as a man who is bitten by a dog simultaneously detests water and desperately needs it, so does the monarchical subject “wanteth nothing more than a strong monarch, which nevertheless out of a certain tyrannophobia, or fear of being strongly governed, when they have him, they abhor” (Hobbes 217). Hobbes concludes that subjects in a monarchy hate what they have. More specifically, they hate what they need: a strong monarch. The democratic writings of Greeks, Latins, and Romans aggravate such revolutionary sentiments until they erupt into action – the very notion that weakens a monarch most and threatens Hobbes’ philosophical foundations more than anything.

Gavin’s Writer Bio

Hometown: Edina, Minnesota.

(Intended) Major: English (Creative Writing).

Favorite Authors: Arthur Miller or Kurt Vonnegut.

Preferred Writing Mode: Dramatic Writing (short fiction, screenplays, stageplays).

On-campus Writing Spot: Davis Family Library Study Carrels

Best Writing Feedback Received: Be concise.

Advice for Fellow Writers: Exposing yourself to a variety of authors helps in developing your own writing style. Whenever possible, too, write what you are most passionate about.

Anything to Share: “There is nothing to writing. All you do is sit down at a typewriter and bleed.” -Ernest Hemingway.

 

 

License

Share This Book