The Manifestation of Oppression in Beloved and The Handmaid’s Tale
Kiki Srivikorn
Toni Morrison and Margaret Atwood – arguably two of the most renowned female contemporary writers – have blessed the world of literature with novels that delve into the oppression faced by historically disadvantaged social groups. Beloved by Morrison encapsulates the trauma and loss of identity as a result of being subjected to slavery, whilst Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale (1985) illustrates the reduction of women to mere vessels for breeding. Although Beloved (1987) is a historical fiction and The Handmaid’s Tale is a speculative one, both novels explore how the subordinate class of society must face the tragic human cost of oppressive norms that have been long imposed by white men.
In “An Interview with Toni Morrison”, the Beloved writer once stated that “Black people have a story, and that story has to be heard.” It is the suffering of the black community that inspired Morrison to concentrate her novels on the history and cultural inheritance of African Americans (Morrison and McKay). Beloved, in particular, lies at the brink of fantasy and realism: Morrison took inspiration from the real-life story of Margaret Garner, a slave who attempted to murder her four children when she was caught as a fugitive. Morrison’s interest in the “female form of love”, thus, is manifested in her novel that explores whether the love of a mother slave can ever be “too thick” (Moglen). Likewise, the patriarchal society that is central to The Handmaid’s Tale is “built on the foundation of the 17th-century Puritan roots that have always lain beneath the modern-day America we thought we knew” (Atwood). Atwood wanted to create a dystopic United States where its liberal democracy was overthrown by a “literal minded theocratic dictatorship”. Moreover, her views on women as “interesting and important” entities has likely prompted Atwood to center her novel on a female protagonist; after all, we are not “an afterthought of nature” or “secondary players in the human history” – we are the main characters (Atwood)! Beloved and The Handmaid’s Tale were surely written in light of Second Wave Feminism (1960-1980) that gave rise to the current reproductive rights movement which focuses on liberalizing not only the white but all women of color from gender inequality and discrimination. Around the same time, there were increasing racial integrations and opportunities for people of color following the 1964 Civil Rights Act, including affirmative actions and voting rights for minorities. Since then, the political landscape of the United States has been dramatically reshaped for the better; nonetheless, in Morrison’s perspective, we should never let the history of African Americans go forgotten (Schuit and Rogowski).
In order to convey the cruel reality of racist institutions, Morrison is not afraid to employ vivid imagery when illustrating violence. In Beloved, female protagonist Sethe cuts the throat of her own child after her white master attempts to recapture her following her escape. Through her vivid portrayal of Sethe’s blood-soaked daughter “staring between the wet fingers that held her
face so her head wouldn’t fall off”, Morrison exhibits the haunting consequence of slavery; a mother is so traumatized by her experience in bondage to the extent that she would rather see her child dead rather than enslaved (Morrison, Beloved 177). It is instinctive for mothers to possess a strong desire to nurture and protect their child from harm; therefore, Sethe’s conscious act to hurt her own baby also demonstrates how being enslaved leads to psychological impairment as well as permanently damages the ability to make rational and moral choices. To Sethe, being free is the greatest state one can achieve – even if it means being dead – therefore, choosing death for her daughter is her motherly act of love. Although Morrison argues that “it was absolutely the right thing to do” her final verdict is that “it’s the thing you have no right to do”. Sethe does not have the liberty to decide whether her daughter gets to live or die – after all, she has never experienced death herself.
The notion of choosing death in the face of oppression is also explored in Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale. The novel revolves around a fictive totalitarian and patriarchal society, Gilead, which is based upon rigid and traditional Christian principles that legitimize the disempowerment of women. Citizens of Gilead are placed into certain hierarchies based on their assigned role. However, all women in Gilead are submissive to men. Their societal function is contingent on their moral virtue as well as their fertility. After her indoctrination, the novel’s protagonist “Offred” finds herself as a handmaid: a fertile woman whose sole duty is to carry children for an assigned household. The institution has stripped them of their educational and reproductive rights through the employment of violence and control. In the beginning of the novel, Offred states, “I know why there is no glass…it isn’t running away they’re afraid of…it’s those other escapes, the ones you can open in yourself, given a cutting edge” (Atwood, Handmaid 9). Atwood ultimately alludes to the suicide of handmaids as a result of the severe oppression that they face. Atwood’s choice of the word “escape” conveys death not as the inevitable end of life, but as a way to free oneself from the repressive regime. Like Sethe, some handmaids choose to not live at all if it means they can be free from the endless suffering of oppression.
In response to learning about the previous handmaid’s death, Offred’s ironical analogy “if your dog dies, get another” implies that society values handmaids no more than animals; they are merely replaceable instruments that lack any moral or intellectual capabilities (Atwood, Handmaid 396). Society’s dehumanization of handmaids, thus, reduce them to a uterus that allows ‘superior’ white men to profit. Similarly, in Beloved, Sethe draws comparisons between herself and a goat, stating that the vile white boys “handled [her] like [she] was the cow, no, the goat” after being raped and ‘milked’ (236). Morrison’s use of animalistic imagery illustrate the severe degradation slaves had to endure from their oppressive force. Paul D expresses feeling as
though a rooster was “better…stronger, tougher” and most importantly, possesses more freedom than he himself (85). Morrison aims to portray the treatment of slaves as livestock: they, too, were no more than tools for labor and economic profit. When schoolteacher – a white male, unsurprisingly – discovers that Sethe had injured and murdered her own children, he stated, “you just can’t mishandle creatures and expect success” (176). Rather than understanding that Sethe’s actions were driven from his own inhumane and abusive acts, he still views her as an animal that was not tended properly. Moreover, “success” in this case likely refers to the productivity that you would expect from a farm animal, which further suggests that the schoolteacher does not view Sethe as a human being, but as a mere breeder of slaves.
In order to marginalize and oppress a certain group, the oppressors classify them by a distinct feature or characteristic. In Beloved and the institution of slavery, the workers are distinguished by the color of their skin and their heritage. Those with ‘darker’ skin were automatically perceived as inferior and lesser human beings – this prejudice is what leads to such awful oppression of the minority. In Atwood’s novel, the handmaids, too, were distinguished, but by the clothing that they were forced to wear rather than by an inherited trait. In Offred’s narrative voice, she states that “everything except the wings around my face is red: the color of blood, which defines us” (10). Red in this sense may connote to menstruation, womanhood, and fertility. Offred’s acknowledgement that she is defined by “blood” suggests that she is aware of the sole role that society has forced her to conform to: a birth giver. Everything about the classification of a handmaid’s outfit alludes to the regime’s violation of rights: the “ankle-length” skirt serves the purpose of a handmaid’s modesty – they are to refrain from engaging in sexual acts other than the ceremonious ones; the “white wings” that prevent others from seeing them enforces the handmaids to remain in isolation, preventing any chance for conspiratorial interaction and therefore the social order is maintained. The administration of the uniform itself is an act of oppression through the restriction of self-expression and creation of identity.
In response to Beloved, scholar Marianne Hirsch once argued that “when Sethe tries to explain to Beloved why she cut her throat, she is explaining an anger handed down through generations of mothers who could have no control over their children’s lives, no voice in their upbringing”. Interestingly, both the slavery institution and the fictional Gilead regime in The Handmaid’s Tale enforce the separation of the oppressed group from their families; enslaved mothers and their children were often spread across several plantations, whilst the handmaids were removed from their families without explanations. Whether it be during the horrific Holocaust or the recent migrant crisis, clearly, the separation of families has long been a tactic of oppressive regimes.
In both novels, any individual who tries to rebel against the regime faces severe and violent consequences. Sethe, for instance, was subject to a brutal beating after she reports the schoolteacher’s nephew for assault. After Halle, Paul A, Sixo, and Paul D attempt to escape the repressive institution, they are severely punished – either burned alive, hanged, or affixed with an iron bit in their mouth. Paul D, after a failed attempt to kill his master Brandywine, was sent to a prison camp where he was subject to both hardship and humiliation. Chained together by the leg, Paul D and the other prisoners had to endure harsh labor and violent treatment from the white guards. Each morning, the black men were forced on their knees, and some were horrifically ordered to perform oral sex on the guards; to refuse meant that they “chose gunshotin [their] head as the price”, signifying that the slaves could not disobey the ones in power and preserve their dignity without sacrificing their life (127). Likewise, women who did not conform to the Gileadean regime were hanged or sent to the “colonies” where they became victims of slavery. The lynching of ‘criminals’ prevails in both novels and this is no coincidence: in oppressive regimes, incumbents tend to impose punishment that can be practiced publicly as to instill fear in the oppressed. Ultimately, this reduces the likelihood of a revolt, keeping the marginalized group subserviently under their control whilst maintaining their supremacy. Gilead refers to the ‘sinners’ of their society as “Unwomen”, indicating that those who could not adhere to their role as a ‘woman’ – which is apparently defined by whether or not one can bear a child or satisfy the desires of men – would ultimately have no place in society. “Moira”, a fearless and opinionated handmaid is the embodiment of rebellion and the representation of women who refuse to conform to the misogynistic expectations of the regime. Offred compares her to “an elevator with open sides”, indicating that Moira’s defiant nature came with danger, and that Offred – like other handmaids – was beginning to succumb to compliance (75). Moira, on the other hand, refuses to become deferent, which eventually drives her to escape the institution as a whole before becoming captured and tortured as a result. Faced with two horrific choices, Moira chooses to work as a prostitute rather than go to the Colonies, indicating that even the most determined insurgent could not attain freedom and would become enslaved in the patriarchy she so strenuously fought against.
Identity is central to both novels; loss of identity is not only the tragic consequence of oppression, but it is the tool that oppressors use to strip their subordinates of power. Perhaps “there are few mirrors” in Gilead because mirrors provide a reflection of oneself – one’s identity and individuality (10). The regime, which aims to perpetuate uniformity and compliance, must reduce the risks of a handmaid realizing her self worth as a human being. In the beginning of The Handmaid’s Tale, Offred tries desperately to retain her sense of self and refuses to claim ownership of the objects Gilead has provided for her. For instance, she states, “the door of the room, not my room…”, but later on in the novel, her attempts to maintain that ‘self’ decayed inexorably; she capitulated to the regime that psychologically broke her down, and eventually calls the room “mine” (10). Even her real name – a key representation of one’s identity – has been robbed from her, leaving Offred with a label that was derived from her Commanders name, “Of” and “Fred”. Her ‘name’ essentially denotes that she belongs to someone else – she has no true identity. Atwood also reveals that her ‘name’ conceals another possibility: to be “offered”, which signifies her as “a religious offering or a victim offered for sacrifice” (Atwood). Similarly, the names of the slaves in Beloved were also stripped away and replaced by the names of their white masters; they are seen as mere property or belongings. Denver, however, was born in the midst of Sethe’s journey to freedom; therefore, Sethe had the ‘privilege’ to choose her own daughter’s name. Although to be able to name one’s child should not have to be a privilege, to a slave, this was one of the greatest forms of liberty and a protection of their legacy.
In both Beloved and The Handmaid’s Tale, the protagonist aims to liberate herself from the regime; where Offred’s symbol of escape is education, Sethe finds herself having to face the past in order to claim ownership of her freed self. The regime in The Handmaid’s Tale utilizes education – or the lack of – to systematically oppress the marginalized population, forbidding women to read and write since education is the key to empowerment. Offred desperately tries to hold onto the memories of the books she has read; but this, too, fades away. Her remaining memories – such as her job, her husband, the successes and failures of everyday life – are the only tools to help her recall a sense of self (Stillman and Johnson). Likewise, Sethe must also confront her memories in order to empower herself once more. As Morrison puts it, “[Sethe’s] past…is haunting – the way memory never really leaves you unless you have gone through it” (Rothstein). For Sethe, to remember the brutality of slavery – be it infanticide, rape, or torture – is to permit herself to grieve in psychologically and spiritually meaningful ways. Memory, in essence, will aid the retainment of our identity until it is strong enough to resist any repression.
Morrison once stated that “my world did not shrink because I was a black female writer. It just got bigger”; she was aware that as a woman of color and a writer, she possessed the ability to empower her own people (Rothstein). By reconceptualizing American history, Morrison showcases the realities of slavery through the acts and consciousness of an enslaved women – one whose voice has not yet been heard by society (Krumholz). She unveils the physical and psychological consequences of slavery and white brutality, encouraging her readers to not evade ‘rememory’ – we must not forget the history of American slavery. Unlike Morrison, the events in Atwood’s novel are merely imaginative; however, many concepts in The Handmaid’s Tale stem from real oppression that has occurred or is still occurring. Undeniably, the most shocking revelation is Atwood’s infamous axiom: nothing is included in the novel that hadn’t happened somewhere in the world. Morrison’s novel encourages us to remember the past, whilst Atwood warns us of the future, “basic civil liberties are seen as endangered, along with many of the rights for women won over the past decades, and indeed the past centuries” (Atwood). Remembering the past bestows us with the knowledge and strength to resist forms of oppression in the future. When the past is silenced, the future is doomed, and then, perhaps, the horrific historical events in Morrison’s novel and the shocking details in Atwood’s dystopian world may very well become reality again…?
Works Cited
Atwood, Margaret. “Margaret Atwood on What ‘the Handmaid’s Tale’ Means in the Age of Trump.” The New York Times, 10 Mar. 2017, www.nytimes.com/2017/03/10/books/review/margaret-atwood-handmaids-tale-age-of trump.html.
Atwood, Margaret. The Handmaid’s Tale. Salem Press, 2010.
Hirsch, Marianne. The Mother-Daughter Plot : Narrative, Psychoanalysis, Feminism. Indiana University Press, 1993.
Krumholz, Linda. “The Ghosts of Slavery: Historical Recovery in Toni Morrison’s Beloved.” African American Review, vol. 26, no. 3, 1992, pp. 395–408, https://doi.org/10.2307/3041912.
Moglen, Helene. “Redeeming History: Toni Morrison’s ‘Beloved.’” Cultural Critique, no. 24, 1993, p. 17, https://doi.org/10.2307/1354128.
Morrison, Toni. Beloved. 1987. Vintage, Cop, 2004.
Morrison, Toni, and Nellie McKay. “An Interview with Toni Morrison.” Contemporary Literature, vol. 24, no. 4, 1983, p. 413, https://doi.org/10.2307/1208128.
ROTHSTEIN, MERVYN. “Toni Morrison, in Her New Novel, Defends Women.” Archive.nytimes.com, 26 Aug. 1987, archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/98/01/11/home/14013.html. Schuit,
Sophie, and Jon C. Rogowski. “Race, Representation, and the Voting Rights Act.” American Journal of Political Science, vol. 61, no. 3, 2017, pp. 513–26, www.jstor.org/stable/26379507?searchText=voting+rights+act&searchUri=%2Faction% 2FdoBasicSearch%3FQuery%3Dvoting%2Brights%2Bact%26so%3Drel&ab_segments= 0%2FSYC6398%2Ftest&refreqid=fastlydefault%3A6db41b4764d2c67a37100a40dd5042ae&seq=.
Stillman, Peter G., and S. Anne Johnson. “Identity, Complicity, and Resistance in the Handmaid’s Tale.” Utopian Studies, vol. 5, no. 2, 1994, pp. 70–86, www.jstor.org/stable/20719314?searchText=the+handmaid%27s+tale&searchUri=%2Fa ction%2FdoBasicSearch%3FQuery%3Dthe%2Bhandmaid%2527s%2Btale%26so%3Drel &ab_segments=0%2Fbasic_search_gsv2%2Fcontrol&refreqid=fastlydefault%3Afd3e89197e1eb2790aab54b636d529fa&seq=1.
Kiki’s Writer Bio
Hometown: Bangkok, Thailand.
(Intended) Major: International and Global Studies.
Favorite Author: Haruki Murakami.
Preferred Writing Mode: Journaling.
On-campus Writing Spot: Davis Family Library.
Best Writing Feedback Received: To be told that my prose sings and has the ability to encourage readers to reflect on the political divide that America is experiencing.
Advice for Fellow Writers: You will write with so much more flair and authenticity when writing about a topic or a theme that you are passionate about. The essay that I was nominated for was one where I wrote about gender inequality and female oppression – the social issue that is closest to my heart. Moreover, while you must be confident in your own beliefs and interpretation, ensure that you remain open-minded to the perspectives of others.