An Enviable Menace: Audre Lorde’s Exploration of Discrimination, Resistance, and a Twisted Envy of Resilience

Walker Coyle

Why does society despise the infamous roach? Is it its brownness, its strong yet frightening stature, and size, or its seemingly indestructible nature? This insect has found itself in the crosshairs of American societal disdain. Its name is synonymous with pest, disgust, deviousness. But is the roach a true menace or is it just a creature with an unrelenting knack for survival even in the direst of circumstances? It is often said that in the event of a nuclear fallout the only survivors will be roaches and Twinkies. In Audre Lorde’s poem, “The Brown Menace, or Poem to the Survival of Roaches,” Lorde champions the detested roach and intertwines its overlooked virtues to that of human resistance. The speaker, the detested Roach, forces the reader to consider and grapple with the roach within themselves. Do we secretly envy the unique attributes of the roach, are we terrified of those attributes, or do we see some of ourselves and our own humanity in an insect we so sincerely despise? Lorde unpacks this internal battle in her poem.  In what seems like a direct and profound statement to white America and its biased societal structures, the speaker, a lowly roach, demands that the audience “Call [hit].” This action attempts to reclaim what the true meaning of being a roach is: to be resilient, to withstand and persevere in the face of incredible pressure and prejudices, and to survive anyway. This poem suggests that to be a roach is similar to being a Person of Color in America. Lorde conveys the idea that both roaches and People of Color are treated as unwanted nuisances shunned for their resilience and feared for surviving in the most unforgiving circumstances while suggesting that their very capacity for survival is something enviable.

Lorde both begins and ends her poem with a focus on survival and its dichotomous meaning. The opening lines read, “Call me/your deepest urge toward survival.” What is survival? Is it the continued life of one’s physical body, or perhaps an unrelenting attitude of perseverance in the face of hostility? In either case, the roach has mastered it. Human nature drives the need and desire to survive and is reflected by the symbol of the roach. The roach is unique because the more we try to destroy it, smoke it out, and limit its boundaries, the more resilient and prone to survival it becomes. This is what terrifies us. The roach has a power that we both so desperately desire, yet simultaneously try to destroy. This loathing is born from jealousy of a strength humans know they cannot possess. Just as humans call pest control to disrupt and control roach communities, America uses systemic injustice to discourage and dismiss People of Color. Hundreds of years of slavery, dozens of years of Jim Crow Laws, and more recently deeply rooted systemic issues have plagued the Black communities in America. But very much like the roach, Lorde implies that this community has an unrelenting knack for perseverance and survival. Even in the most unfathomable circumstances, People of Color find ways to survive and often thrive in a society that was taught to marginalize them. Not unlike the roach, People of Color are feared by a society attempting to exterminate them and are therefore loathed for their unrelenting survivability and capacity to flourish regardless.

Throughout the work, the Speaker repeats the phrase “call me.” In fact, those words open the poem and both stanzas. “Call me.” Who wants to be called, and to whom are they calling? It is the Roach that harbors the burden of disdain and judgment who narrates this poem. It makes a demanding and challenging cry, “call me/ roach and presumptuous/ nightmare on your white pillow.” Why would someone ask to be called a roach and willingly accept the title of one of society’s most notorious menaces? The roach, serving as a symbol, entity, and speaker offers the audience two messages; firstly, it wants us to address our presumptions of the nature of the roach, and secondly, it urges us to confront the roach within. It says, “call me/ your own determination/ in the most detestable shape.” It implies that the roach, whom we agree to loathe, is really a representation of perseverance and strength that we simply cannot attain. Its very existence threatens our structures and challenges the power we believe we hold. Therefore, the roach is not something we hate but a desire we shun because we cannot achieve. Regardless, in the shadows, we unknowingly strive to be more like the roach, but we will never fully achieve this because we were born with the privilege of being human. The roach acknowledges this twisted truth when it claims, “as I alter–/ through your greedy preoccupations/ through your kitchen wars/ and your poisonous refusal–/ to survive.”  Poison, the cowardly weapon wielded against all roaches, is in this case, refusal. Refusal is such a simple yet devastating and overarching concept. Its poison extends everywhere, the refusal of equity, the refusal of recognition of inequity, the refusal to act, but most importantly a refusal to change. This refusal to change was ingested into the existing power structures at their creation. Society has been drinking this poison so long it forgets that despite our humanity, each possesses the roach within themselves. The Roach proclaims, “you learn to honor me/ by imitation” and acknowledges the unspoken fact that our drive for survival, prosperity, and growth is identical to the nature of the roach.

The detested roach serves as a symbol for People of Color in America. In order to survive, they’ve had to adapt and as a result, both roaches and People of Color have built an incredibly powerful resilience to the structures that oppress them. In this analogy, the roach is to humans as People of Color are to white America. The white America we live in today cannot exist without the oppression of Black and Brown Americans. Just as we fear the roach because of their unique survivability, the current system is terrified because over three hundred years of oppression has created resilience and power in People of Color that white Americans cannot understand and therefore feel threatened by. It is often the things that we feel most vulnerable about in ourselves that we in turn loath in others. The inability to understand and comprehend the resilience of People of Color who not only exist but strengthen under adversity leaves White America vulnerable and confused. How can People of Color be both repressed and detested, yet demonstrate such strength and resilience? The speaker, a roach, urges white America to confront its subconscious and conscious biases toward People of Color, and then challenges them to see themselves reflected in its own form. “Call me/your own determination/in the most detestable shape/you can become/friend of your image/within me/I am you.” The roach, symbolic of what White America is trying to eradicate, reveals that the interconnectedness of what is both desired and loathed exists within it. The perplexing ability to survive desired, but the creature itself despised.

Engrained in the fiber of a roach’s being is a telling dichotomy of beauty and ugliness. These abstract and often illusive concepts are almost impossible to definitively capture because the recognition of each fall entirely in the eyes of the beholder. Therefore, it is the reader that must decide whether they find the roach to be a symbol of strength and admirability or of disdain and disgust. Interestingly, this choice is given before the poem even begins, not so subtly hidden in the title “The Brown Menace, or Poem to the Survival of Roaches.” In this title each reader reaches a metaphorical crossroads. This crossroads being the recognition of beauty or ugliness, the recognition of a menace or of a survivor. The title presents two frameworks through which the reader can interpret the roach. The first is sympathy and understanding. It is “A Poem To” those who have borne the disdain of society and used its hate to strengthen their own resistance. In the other case it challenges those who envy and distrust the resilient. If the roach is seen as “The Brown Menace” then the reader will have their opinion and privilege contested. It is in this way that the poem creates a duality which challenges the reader’s perception of society and beauty. It is the roach who is certain of who it is, while it is the reader who is left to discover and reveal themself in its call.

Walker’s Writer Bio

Hometown: Boise.

(Intended) Major: History.

Favorite Author/Book: Water for Elephants, Sara Gruen.

Preferred Writing Mode: Self Reflective.

On-campus Writing Spot: The Chateau common rooms.

Best Writing Feedback Received: If you are not feeling in the mood to write go out and visit the outdoors, friends, or anything you enjoy. It will always lead to more thoughtful and clear work.

Advice for Fellow Writers: If you write about subjects you are passionate about it will always come easier and appear more genuine.

Anything to Share: Enjoy First Year Seminar, it’s a great time to develop your skills and style as a writer.

 

License

Share This Book