I am America: The Spiritual Reconciliation of the Individual and the Nation
Beck Kendig
“It occurs to me that I am America.” Why does this statement mean so much more than, “It occurs to me that I am American”? One letter is all it takes to relieve the central tension in Allen Ginsberg’s poem “America”. A single “n” and the speaker is free from the burden and shame of embodying America. He joins us readers as just another American fed up with the faults of a country we live in. Instead, Ginsberg refuses to distinguish the American voice of his poem from America itself. His speaker is “talking to [himself],” and everything he says, from the personal to the political, demands of America some response or at least an acknowledgment. The stream of consciousness that emerges from this uncomfortable, conflicted internal dialogue can be examined through intertwined examples of confession and petition. The speaker, as proxy for America, confesses to his faults and absurdities while simultaneously petitioning America to listen and accept those imperfections. Within this dichotomy both speaker and country are equally flawed as are all the rest of us passively discontented Americans. The question then is not how to separate America from the individual so that one or the other might be sensible and good. Rather, it is through the sincerity of our shared exposure that we understand we are all in fact America. To criticize our collective is to criticize ourselves, and in turn to uplift ourselves is to uplift our collective. The poem moves us to consider what progress could look like if we as Americans refuse to blame America and instead examine the blind spots of our own absurdity. If we tell the truth about who we really are, we can, “Get right down to the job,” demanding America represent that reality.
I can imagine another form of this poem titled, “Allen.” In it, America acts as the primary speaker, confessing to its possession of nuclear warheads, involvement in needless war, and obsession with consumerism and greed. America would explain all of this, pleading to a single near-sighted, bohemian poet called Allen hoping for something like salvation. How would this role-reversal change the poem? In the real poem the speaker is conjoined to America, but his role as the confessor aligns him beneath the larger entity of the country. When he says, “America, I’ve given you all and now I’m nothing,” we see the speaker as self-deprecating and small. He is a giver who wants to be a saint. He smokes marijuana, “Every chance [he] [gets],” and, “Can’t stand [his] own mind.” Altogether, he is psychopathic, overwhelmed, obsessed, romantic, and pathetic, but he owns up to these flaws with an enthusiasm bordering on pride. This is the mind Ginsberg chose to align with America because through this perspective we can’t see America as something inconceivably evil and strange. We are conditioned to accept and even applaud absurdity in the narrator before we are conditioned to conjoin the speaker with America. Therefore, an extension of that acceptance toward America becomes plausible. An example of this movement appears in the line, “Are you being sinister or is this some form of practical joke?” This statement is addressed to America and questions whether we can see the country through the same lens of lenient absurdity with which we view the speaker. It’s much harder to give America the same benefit of the doubt, but a path for that perspective has been cleared. It’s up to us whether we follow it. To return to that original question of role-reversal, the poem does not begin, “Allen I’ve given you all and now I’m nothing,” because Allen is not the figure we are truly trying to understand or reason with. Rather, his confessed absurdity is a vehicle to viewing the nation in a similar light. This transferal requires the speaker to be a flawed human being rather than a flawed country. As readers, we understand and empathize with imperfect people on the page. They reveal parts of ourselves we do our best to hide, allowing us to briefly and silently enjoy the freedom to be flawed. When the speaker says, “I sit in my house for days on end and stare at roses in the closet,” I can connect with his loneliness, his stagnancy, and I can see how the imagery of the flowers and the closet imply closeted homosexuality.
It is through these moments of confessional intimacy between speaker and reader that we begin to empathize with America as well. As we move through the poem, the speaker officially announces, “I am America.” This turning point in the poem forces us to reconsider our empathy and appreciation of the narrator’s honest absurdity. The America criticized throughout the first stanza is now one with the absurd speaker we’ve come to accept. In addition to his aforementioned weed, the speaker now confesses to possessing, “Twentyfive-thousand mental institutions,” along with, “Prisons,” and, “Millions of underprivileged who live in my flower pots.” One could read this confession as a metaphor that implies complicity but doesn’t account to reasonable blame because, well, it’s only a metaphor. I would argue that the speaker knows he is not so innocent. The line, “Everybody’s serious but me,” reveals an understanding of his unique place in America. As a poet caught up in the world of ideas rather than a businessman, a soldier, a factory worker, a political official, he has distanced himself from the serious side of America even as he attempts to condemn its nature. He is in one way raised above these roles and institutions through his radical individuality and protest, and in another mired in the responsibility of knowing they still exist as he talks to himself, smokes weed, and reads Time Magazine. This is a poem about the ownership of sin. Can a man or a country be redeemed through confession? “America when will you be angelic?” asks the poem. There is no telling when, but the desire for salvation opens the door to the only possible route: petition and hope.
Interspersed between the speaker’s confessions, this poem poses questions to the nation that appeal to the common theme of understanding and accepting absurdity. These questions act as petitions, and through consideration of their motivations and potential outcomes we witness the conception of a more honest, brighter America. The line, “When will you be angelic?” allows us to imagine a truly good nation just as we might sometimes catch a glimpse of the person we hope to become. This internal correlation is best described in the opening of the third stanza by the question, “America how can I write a holy litany in your silly mood?” A litany is by definition, “A liturgical prayer consisting of a series of petitions recited by a leader alternating with fixed responses by the congregation.” This poem is a litany in which the speaker acts as the leader and his personification of America acts as the congregation. He asks how to write a holy questioning about America that can be answered and agreed upon, when the only commonality between America and himself is their mutual absurdity or “silly mood.” In the next line, the speaker answers his own question from both his and America’s point of view: “I will continue like Henry Ford my strophes are as individual as his automobiles they’re all/different sexes.” Here Ginsberg merges America’s obsession with consumerism and industry with the speaker’s obsession with poetry in such a way that they both seem equally strange and yet important in the way of progress. Every time the speaker makes a petition, he opens himself and America. He admits who he is and what he cares about while forcing America to respond. The longest line in the poem prods America with an anecdote of their shared history and claims, “The speeches were free everybody was angelic and/sentimental about the workers it was all so sincere you have no idea what a good thing the party was.” Although this scene does not describe the more modern America to which the poem is addressed, it is still America. The freedom, holiness, and sincerity of the since disavowed party describes such a tender point of contact between speaker and country that both are compelled to ask what happened? “Everybody must have/been a spy,” answers the poem, but what if they weren’t? What if America freed Tom Mooney and saved the Spanish Loyalists? What if America refused to go to war? What if America could speak? The purpose of petition in this poem is not to provide any answers. The responses exist in the possibilities swimming through the speaker’s mind and ours’. Afterall, we are America. We decide what we become.
In reading and discussing this poem, I often returned to an idea raised in the first stanza that seemed almost out of place. “There must be some other way to settle this argument,” says the speaker amid his confessions and petitions. What stood out to me was the sentence’s lack of a subject. Neither the speaker nor America appear outside of context. I had a feeling this was one moment in which Allen Ginsberg was most present as the author of this poem. With nearly two pages of poetry to write, he stops to wonder if this absurd stream of internal dialogue and strategy of building acceptance through confession before begging progress through petition is the best way to write his poem. Surely there were other ways to write this – think of Claude McKay’s poem by the same title, which employs the firm structure of sonnet, or my proposed “Allen” piece. The reality is that Ginsberg could only write this poem as he did. His poetry is his contribution to the serious job of making right the mess that is America. It is our mess, our country, our individuality that demands to be seen.
Throughout the poem, the speaker and America move together toward a place of increased understanding despite their differences, but does this clarity guarantee spiritual reconciliation? In the original draft of “America” Ginsberg concludes by shoving a figurative wedge between the speaker and his country. The final lines, “Dark America! toward whom I close my eyes for prophecy,/and bend my speaking heart! /Betrayed! Betrayed!” (Wikipedia), alienate America as the speaker’s evil, alternative consciousness. The contract of trust forged throughout the poem is broken. Our empathy for America disappears along with our hope for the speaker, and the poem ends there. Except, it doesn’t. Through revision – a writing practice he rarely entertained during his career as a poet – Ginsberg chose to end in a moment of action and vulnerability. By, “Putting [his] queer shoulder to the wheel,” the speaker takes ownership of his absurd, unconventional nature while alluding again to his bisexuality. Within the historic figure of speech that is putting one’s shoulder to the wheel, the word “queer” reveals Ginsberg’s radical choice to help push America out of its spiritual rut. That image of Ginsberg, his balding head, his circular glasses, his wise smirk twisted with exertion as he heaves his shoulder against a big wooden cart labelled “America”, makes me believe it can be done. Inevitably, we are moved to join him.
Beck’s Writer Bio
Hometown: Carlisle, Massachusetts.
(Intended) Major: Film and Media Culture.
Favorite Author/Book: My favorite book at the moment is The Sirens by Kurt Vonnegut.
Preferred Writing Mode: Fiction.
On-campus Writing Spots: On the second story of Davis Library in the big blue chairs facing the entrance.
Best Writing Feedback Received: I was told years ago that writing should always strive toward truth. No matter what I am writing about, I try to represent both myself and my subject authentically.
Advice for Fellow Writers: Middlebury writing professors are fantastic people to know. Also, events like readings and writing opportunities are there for you.
Anything to Share: I look forward to reading my peers’ writing!