A Crisis of Masculinity: A Look into Postindustrial Gym Culture

Charlotte Cebula

The topic of male performances of masculinity as they relate to bodybuilding and  recreational gym use has garnered attention from sociologists worldwide as it showcases an exaggerated demonstration of hegemonic masculinity. Studies focus on a wide range of issues  pertaining to the emergent “gym culture,” such as an individual’s relationship to the fitness  industry and its community, the layout of gyms as a reflection of power structures, and particular  “health” practices centered around bodybuilding. The term “body work” can be best used to  encompass a variety of manhood acts that pertain to this topic. Body work pertains to the  practices, such as dieting, exercise regimes, and taking supplements, that one performs on their  own body in order to achieve an aesthetic modification or maintain a specific physique.[1] An  overarching theme of a “crisis of masculinity” as a result of a new postindustrial world can be  seen across these studies. In turn, this crisis typically fuels white, middle to working class men to become increasingly reliant on body work as an assertion of masculinity. Though the research on  gym culture touches on a variety of different themes and includes data collected from a plethora  of gym users worldwide, there is significant continuity in the notion of the “ideal male,” the  layout of a fitness center as it relates to masculinity, and the emergence of an exaggerated  manhood act following industrialization.

Though some outliers existed, most of the men interviewed in the ethnographic studies of  gym masculinity pointed to a similar “ideal” male form, of which they pursued with  bodybuilding and food consumption practices. Additionally, the idealized male body is often

contrasted with the undesirable form. The presence of a soft body is not only undesirable, but  also associated with laziness and a lack of masculinity. According to the men in Julia Coffey’s  2015 study, the ideal male body is “visibly muscular, with broad shoulders and a flat stomach.”[2] This body type is similarly defined in both Yvonne Weigers’ and Christian Vaccaro’s studies as  “mesomorph.” Muscular mesomorph is the body type seen as most desirable by males. It is  attributed to physical strength and potency, dominance over others, physical activity, and  control.[3][4] The mesomorph has a developed chest, noticeable arm muscles, wide shoulders, and a  narrow waist. Moreover, this body type is theorized to be the highest embodiment of masculinity  in society.[5]It is in pursuit of the mesomorph body type, most often undertaken at the gym, that  men can perform masculinity and cultivate a masculine identity. Thus, the gym itself is an  important place of study as it is a hotbed of manhood acts and identity formation.

Though many studies focused primarily on the individuals themselves who performed  masculinity through the pursuit of an idealized body image, much of the literature emphasized  the physical qualities of the gyms themselves and how they impacted the clientele. According to  Justin Conley’s 2000 study, there exist two distinct types of gyms: the “chromed-up health spa”  and the “hardcore” gym.[6] For the purposes of looking at manhood acts in their extreme forms,  studies of the “hardcore” gym are more fruitful. Whereas “health spas” cater to middle class  professionals, “hardcore” gyms are the preferred location for bodybuilders. The equipment at  “hardcore” gyms fits the needs of serious bodybuilders; instead of complex machinery and aerobic classes, these gyms prioritize heavy free weights. This equipment is seen as more  dangerous and therefore more masculine, as greater skill is required for safe use.[7] Moreover, the  bodybuilding gym serves as a locus of male fraternity and camaraderie. As a site of “collective  toil,” gyms create fraternal networks of support and friendship. Moreover, when pubs and bars  host the social scene for many men, the gym creates its own social scene in accordance with its  ethos of “wellness.”[8] According to Thomas Johansson’s 1996 study, the men who use the  bodybuilding domain of the gym can, in effect, develop a subculture unique to gyms.[9] Unique  hierarchies develop within the heavy lifting areas of the gym, and conversations about dieting  and supplement consumption practices flourish. Furthermore, the augmentation in gyms  worldwide can be attributed to the effects of industrialization and its decline in influence.

An overarching drive for men to participate in “body work” can be traced to a “crisis in  masculinity” fueled by changing labor practices in a postindustrial society. The research of  Nicholas Gibbs, Mike Salinas, and Luke Turnock heavily emphasized this connection between  the shift away from industrial labor and the increase in bodybuilding gyms. Though their  ethnographic data focuses specifically on small, former industrial cities of Great Britain, the  trend of a “masculinity crisis” can be seen in other parts of the world, such as the United States  and Australia. In Great Britain, the process of de-industrialization began in the late 1970s, as the  country began to globally outsource goods and privatize traditional industries that were formerly  operated by entire towns and cities. As the demand for entirely male industrial workspaces, such  as factories and docks, dissolved, the sense of collective identity, camaraderie, and fraternal community became more difficult to find. Through earning wealth through communal toil, men  in industrial towns looked to work for pride in their craft and labor.[10] Following the industrial  era, men turned to employment in traditionally more female-occupied sectors, such as service.  According to Vaccaro, this phenomenon created a “contemporary crisis of masculinity” that led  to increased reliance on body work to assert manhood.[11] Moreover, Great Britain and the United  States in the late 19th century experienced a growing fear that industrialization would lead white  middle-class men to become weak and effeminate, unable to fight in wars, and incapable of  expanding national frontiers.[12] Unable to assert manhood through daily labor, men turned to  body work in order to reject femininity and seek out a masculine-oriented space. According to  Michael Atkinson, “work in the postindustrial economy and associated lifestyles are not easily  reconciled for [white men] with traditional images of the powerful, performing, and  dominant male”[13] In fact, as more women join the workforce, thereby “feminizing” the space,  many men in turn pursue a masculine identity through supplementation and bodybuilding  practices.[14]

The bulk of the sociological research on gym culture focuses on the creation of male  communities and the broader implications of dieting and supplementation. However, in  discussing masculinity it is imperative to look at its relation to women and upholding of the  patriarchy. In Thomas Johansson’s ethnographic study of three Swedish gyms, the gender divide  between male and female was clearly seen. The gym as a space is not only distinguishable by the  intensity of its bodybuilding focus, but also along the lines of gender. For example, certain regions of the gym, such as the front, are informally designated to be feminine. Moreover, in the  shared spaces, specific machines are regarded as more feminine than others. The distinction  between men and women in a body work setting can be seen more broadly in the media. For  example, internationally recognized bodybuilder Arnold Schwarzenegger differentiated male  “bodybuilding” from women’s “body shaping,” even though both practices entail similar  behaviors.[15] Looking to the future, studies on how male behavior and consumption of  performance-enhancing products effects women not only in the gym, but in daily life. Does a  desire to return to a more “traditionally masculine” body shape bring with it other more  regressive ideologies? Can the studies of the manosphere overlap with those of male body work?  Given that performances of masculinity in pursuit of the hegemonic masculine ideal often  subjugate women’s place in society, the study of masculinities could be enhanced by research  into the ways in which women are placed at a disadvantage through the male pursuit of the  mesomorph body type.

Charlotte’s Writer Bio

Hometown: New York City.

(Intended) Major: History.

Favorite Author/Book: Delia Owens, Where the Crawdads Sing.

Preferred Writing Mode: History paper.

On-campus Writing Spot: The back tables on the second floor of Davis library! The lighting is the best.

Best Writing Feedback Received: My high school history teacher once told me that long, complicated sentences don’t show off your skill. Be succinct and use powerful verbs. Don’t waste paper space just to sound “intellectual.”

Advice for Fellow Writers: Don’t procrastinate on writing papers. The stress will drive the quality down! Take your time and allow yourself to think.

 


  1. Julia Coffey, “I Put Pressure on Myself to Keep That Body’: ‘Health’-related Body Work, Masculinities and Embodied Identity,’ Social Theory & Health 14, no. 2 (September 2, 2015): 170. ↵
  2. Coffey, “I Put Pressure,” 181. ↵
  3. Christian Alexander Vaccaro, "Male Bodies in Manhood Acts: The Role of Body-Talk and Embodied Practice in  Signifying Culturally Dominant Notions of Manhood," Sociology Compass 5, no. 1 (January 2011): 67. ↵
  4. Yvonne Wiegers, "Male Bodybuilding: The Social Construction of a Masculine Identity," Journal of Popular  Culture 2: 148. ↵
  5. Justin Skye Conley, "Hegemonic Masculinity: Just another Day at the Gym'" (PhD diss., Lakehead University,  2000), 7. ↵
  6. Conley, "Hegemonic Masculinity," 21. ↵
  7. Wiegers, “Male Bodybuilding,” 157. ↵
  8. Nicholas Gibbs, Mike Salinas, and Luke Turnock, "Post-industrial Masculinities and Gym Culture: Graft, Craft,  and Fraternity," The British Journal of Sociology 73, no. 1 (December, 2021): 231. ↵
  9. Thomas Johansson, "Gendered Spaces: The Gym Culture and the Construction of Gender" [Gendered Spaces: The  Gym Culture and the Construction of Gender], YOUNG 4, no. 3 (September 1996): 33. ↵
  10. Gibbs, Salinas, and Turnock, “Post-industrial Masculinities,” 223. ↵
  11. Vaccaro, "Male Bodies," 66. ↵
  12. Wiegers, "Male Bodybuilding," 149. ↵
  13. Atkinson, "Playing with Fire," 180. ↵
  14. Atkinson, "Playing with Fire," 176. ↵
  15. Johansson, “Gendered Spaces,” 35. ↵

License

Share This Book