John Stuart Mill on Freedom of Thought Promoting the Well-being of Society

Daniel Schroeder

Modern society places a great emphasis on the necessity of freedom of speech and expression. It is seen as a universal liberty ingrained in the founding of many countries, and thus was solidified as a core value of society as these countries endured. For example, this freedom is mentioned in the United Nations’ Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the enjoyment of which is one of the highest aspirations of society. Many other examples of constitutional inclusion of freedom of opinions prove that this liberty is considered to be one of utmost importance in modern society. This leads one to question as to why this freedom is so widely regarded as necessary? There must be some great societal benefit gained from the freedom of opinion, otherwise it would not be regarded with such high value. John Stuart Mill aimed to answer this question, among others, in his essay “On Liberty.” He believed that freedom of opinion is a necessary component of a productive society because its existence promotes intellectual progress and mental well-being of the members of a society. Mill provided core grounds for why he believed freedom of thought is necessary to mental well-being and intellectual progress. These grounds are that oppressed ideas may sometimes be true or even partly true, that uncontested opinions end up being held as a prejudice, and that if left long enough these uncontested opinions lose meaning to society altogether.

A discussion of Mill’s ideas of freedom of thought should most logically start with a summary of his writings regarding freedoms and liberties as a whole. He painted a picture of a struggle between liberty and authority in the hands of a governing body. He explained that a powerful ruler used to be “regarded as a necessary, but also highly dangerous; as a weapon which they would attempt to use against their subjects” (Mill 2015 pg5). He then explained how, in order to prevent oppression from this power, members of the society obtained recognition of political liberties and established constitutional checks on power (pg6). If the ruler did not comply, the governed body would revolt, ultimately forcing the ruler into recognizing these rights.  These liberties remained through changes in preference of style of government and were solidified as necessary. Mill laid out liberty of thought, freedom of opinion, liberty of tastes and pursuits, and liberty of combination for non-harmful purposes as the core liberties belonging to a population. He stated that “No society in which these liberties are not (…) respected, is free, (…) and none is completely free in which they do not exist absolute and unqualified” (pg15). He then later explained that freedom of thought provides the best introduction on why these liberties are so vital to the general operation, progress, and well-being of a society.

As he mentioned generally with the other liberties, Mill believed liberty of thought and freedom of expression to be of paramount importance to society, and in this case society’s well-being. He called them universally necessary and explained that “the peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation.” He argued that thought suppressed deprives people of the ability to exchange error for truth and to build their perception of what is right (pg19). Later in his work, he proceeds to provide specific reasons for why this freedom is so important.

The first specific reason that Mill advocated for freedom of thought is that it prevents potentially true opinions from being compelled to silence. He strongly advocated against the silencing of opinions on the grounds that they are wrong. Opponents suggest that there is no harm in silencing a wrong opinion because prohibiting what is thought to be pernicious is fulfilling a duty of acting on conscientious conviction (pg20-1). In other words, it is claimed to be a duty to propagate what is right and quell what is harmful. The only way for this to occur is if the party doing the silencing assumes their position to be the truth. Mill warned of the differences between assuming absolute truth for the purpose of preventing any refutation and the assumption of truth due to genuine irrefutability. The former case results in a scenario where a party silences all opposition just so their ideas cannot be questioned. The danger in this approach is that it results in the potential silencing of genuinely truthful opinions. The only way to prevent silencing of the truth is through free expression and exchange of ideas regardless of how harmful or illogical they are. Mill summed this up by saying that the sole way of achieving certainty is through frequent question and challenge (pg23). In the end, the only way to ensure the prevention of the silencing of truths is through a platform based on Mill’s freedom of thought, in which question and challenge ultimately work to promote genuinely truthful opinions.

The next reason Mill presented for the importance of liberty of thought follows a similar rationale for the prevention of the silencing of truth outlined above.  He explained how without true freedom of thought and expression there will be suppression of opinions that hold part truths. It is especially important that these part truths are preserved because oftentimes the “prevailing opinion on any subject is rarely or never the whole truth” (pg52). Thus, the logical solution to finding the whole truth would be to combine the partial truths of the silenced opinion and those of the prevailing opinion until a whole truth is created. Mill explained this in stating “it is only by the collision of adverse opinions that the remainder of the truth has any chance of being supplied” (pg52). Just as the previous example of suppression of whole truths, the only way to permanently fix this issue is through the free, unadulterated discourse and expression of opinion.

Another potential consequence of the absence of liberty of thought is that opinions widely regarded as true can become obsolete or their origins forgotten. Mill’s remaining core grounds that are the foundation of the necessity of liberty of thought can be categorized this way. He warned that “the mischievous operation of the absence of free discussion, when the received opinions are true, were confined to leaving men ignorant of the grounds of those opinions” and that “not only are the grounds of the opinion forgotten (…) but too often the meaning of the opinion itself” (pg39). This provides a bleak foreshadowing of eventual meaningless opinions and an epidemic of ignorance among the population that “prevent[s] the growth of any real and heartfelt conviction, from reason or personal experience” (pg52). Thus, the only solution to secure growth of intellectual well-being and reason is to ensure free exchange of opinion. This freedom promotes a discourse in which truths are regularly challenged and people think critically about the opinions they hold. This thinking is what allows for the further development of understanding and what secures the meaning of opinions which is conducive to the aforementioned growth of intellect, reason, and well-being.

The main idea of Mill’s argument is that completely free expression of opinions allows for multitudes of different ideas to flood public discourse, and that ultimately this is beneficial for society.  This creates a society in which people need to hear every side of a particular debate before deciding on what is best. This facilitates critical thinking and ultimately cultivates one’s intellect. Mill explained this by saying “Never when controversy avoided the subjects (…) was the mind of a people stirred up from its foundations, and the impulse given which raised [people] (…) to something of the dignity of thinking beings” (pg35). In other words, the controversy resulting from conflicting opinions stirs people to be dignified, thinking beings. In this setting, a person’s overall mental well-being is improved as they navigate and think through the opposing views resulting from the complete freedom of expression and discourse. As Mill wrote, all other well-being depends on mental well-being (pg51), so if mental well-being is promoted then the overall well-being of society is benefited in conjunction. Thus, exposure to diverse opinions, spurred by freedom of opinion, not only allows for the discovery of moral and factual truths through “collision of adverse opinions,” but also cultivates critical thinking and ultimately intellectual well-being and progress of the society in which this freedom of expression is experienced.

Mill himself mentioned and dispelled many potential objections to his claims. For example, a potential objector may see nothing wrong with a system in which dangerous, false claims are censored and true ones are disseminated to the public. It could even be argued that the censorship of potentially harmful opinions is even more conducive to a society’s well-being. However, Mill explained that if one judges opinions, they are ultimately “claiming to be an infallible judge of opinions” (pg24). Mill also pointed out how “everyone well knows himself to be fallible” (pg20), so claiming to be an infallible judge capable of silencing supposedly false opinions goes against the widely regarded fact that humans are not infallible. According to Mill, the truth is only uncovered through the constant questioning and comparing of opinions, and it will naturally endure such questioning. He stated, “The beliefs which we have most warrant for, have no safeguard to rest on, but a standing invitation (…) to prove them unfounded (…) This is the amount of certainty attainable by a fallible being, and this is the sole way of attaining it” (pg23). This means that, due to the fallibility of humans, the process of exposing opinions to adverse ones is the only way to achieve certainty and ultimately intellectual growth of society. Thus, there is never any justification for censorship, even of harmful opinions, because it prevents the process of intellectual enrichment from unfolding.

Another potential shortcoming of Mill’s writing on freedom of thought is exposed when someone is expressing their opinion with some sort of harmful intent. For example, take someone preaching an opinion with the only intent of benefitting from harm caused to those that listen. This could take the form of manipulation, indoctrination, or inculcation purely for the benefit of the one spreading the ideas. Modern examples of this could be seen in a cult leader. Their goal is to manipulate people into subscribing to a system of beliefs purely because it benefits the originator of the ideas. A proponent of Mill’s philosophy might argue that an attempt at indoctrination is just a rightful spread of an opinion. However, it seems this type of action would harm society, so there is a legitimate question as to whether Mill’s ideas regarding freedom of expression would condone such ill-mannered behavior. A response in line with Mill’s ideas can be presented by examining his writings. One of the most obvious rebuttals would be that if Mill’s principles of free expression were followed exactly then there would be an opposing opinion advising against the teachings of a hypothetical cult leader. Thus, one would make their ultimate decision entirely informed by both sides. At this point, the decision is entirely up to the individual and what they feel would benefit them the most. This self-benefit is what Mill believed all decisions should be based on as evidenced by the quote “[a person’s] own mode of laying out his existence is the best, not because it is the best in itself, but because it is his own mode” (pg66). In summary, if freedom of expression is adequately observed, there will be equal and opposite opinions advising against manipulative opinions, and with this access, all that is left is for a person to choose whatever system of beliefs they think fits them best. The ultimate decision, if made in this manner, is best according to Mill’s utilitarian philosophy because it was made by the individual with their own benefit in mind. This means of decision making and opinion forming is how Mill believes society best operates with respect to forming of personal intellectual opinions and informed lifestyles.

In summary, Mill believed that freedom of thought provides a means of discourse and exposure to novel ideas that ultimately strengthens one’s intellectual faculties and mental and overall well-being. This happens through people’s exposure to adverse opinions. A free-thinking society listens to these opinions and comes to its own conclusion about the truth. Mill believed this process of decision making to be what facilitates the intellectual progress and well-being of the society. The suppression of ideas prevents discourse and ultimately the practice of critical thinking necessary for a person to form their own novel opinion. It is this mode of thinking which promotes intellectual progress, and, without it, society is prohibited from progress. Thus, the only way to ensure progress is to provide absolute security to a society’s freedom of opinion and expression. Thus, Mill answered the question of why freedom of expression is so absolutely necessary to modern society. It is vital to the intellectual progress and well-being of society. This explains why the value of freedom of opinion has been so long-lasting: it is recognized to be conducive to overall progress and welfare of society as a whole, just as Mill explained. Obviously, such an important freedom should be preserved universally if a society’s long-term existence is dependent on it. Thus, with Mill’s reasoning in mind, it is perfectly understandable and even expected that the preservation of these freedoms takes such an important role in the foundation of government across most of the world today.

References

Mill, John Stuart. On Liberty, Utilitarianism, and Other Essays. Oxford University Press, 2015.

Daniel’s Writer Bio

Hometown: North Stonington.

(Intended) Major: Physics.

License

Share This Book