Untitled
Caroline Jantzen
In “Why Not Socialism,” G. A. Cohen presents his case for a socialist society. He utilizes the analogy of a camping trip as an example of socialism in action, expanding upon those principles before delving into the desirability and feasibility of the political system. Cohen proposes socialism in direct contrast to capitalism, detailing the latter’s deep impact on societal inequality and general behavior, ultimately advocating for a renouncement of capitalism for socialism. However, this is no easy feat: Cohen himself admits that he has no answer as to how this transition will occur, saying, “the question about feasibility that I am addressing here is not whether socialism is straight-forwardly accessible, whether we can get to it from where we are…” (Cohen 56). Instead, he focuses on socialism’s hypothetical feasibility and stability, given that it is instituted. In the absence of any specific directive from Cohen, what should the socialist reader do to become active in society and reject capitalism? Or, does Cohen’s inability to develop such a call to action further exemplify just how pervasive capitalism is?
To understand Cohen’s argument, the reader must first comprehend his “camping trip.” For the duration of the trip, the campers effectively create their own mini-society in which there exists no hierarchy, a common goal is shared, and facilities become communal. Essentially, they create a socialist utopia, with their “mutual understandings, and the spirit of enterprise” ensuring that no detrimental inequalities arise among the group (Cohen 4). In this setting, people are not rewarded for good fortune, possess no ownership over a shared resource, and do not believe any individual has the right to inheritance of such resource, either. “Isn’t this, the socialist way, with collective property and planned mutual giving[?],” asks Cohen (Cohen 10).
Cohen distills the socialist nature of the imagined camping scenario into two important principles: an egalitarian principle and a community principle. The egalitarian principle, he describes, advances “socialist equality of opportunity,” a concept that “removes obstacles to opportunity from which some people suffer and others don’t, obstacles that are sometimes due to the enhanced opportunities that the more privileged people enjoy” (Cohen 13). Socialist equality of opportunity (contrasted to its bourgeois and left-liberal cousins) accounts for all disadvantages an individual may face, whether social or natural. The only differences in a socialist society would arise from inconsistencies in personal preference or taste (Cohen 18). Differences in preference include one’s labor and consumption: with all working for the same hourly wage, each individual has the freedom to choose their profession and how many hours they work.
As such, certain inequalities emerge (Cohen outlines three major types): first comes the “unproblematic” form of inequality, where differing preferences cause people to garner more of certain assets than others, though their relative happiness remains equal. In the second and third (more problematic) types, an inequality in aggregate benefit arises due to poor choice or “option luck,” causing people to no longer be of equal standing. The most problematic form–option luck–is reflected in the capitalist market: as people decide where to invest their money (and labor), large inequalities surface between the winners and losers. And, because people are so dependent on the market for access to necessities, few have the option to opt-out of what Cohen calls “the gamble” (Cohen 33).
Therein lies the biggest issue confronting Cohen: the seemingly inescapable nature of capitalism. Where the capitalist market rewards greed, the socialist economic system hopes to establish principles of community, reciprocity, and justice. Communal reciprocity–the fundamental concept underlying a socialist economy–relies on people doing things for others who need their service, creating a flow of exchange in which an individual serves someone with the expectation that they will do the same for him. In this system, people are not motivated by profit but by a desire to be a part of a community; here, one can see the spirit of reciprocity in a socialist society (Cohen 40).
At this point, Cohen’s socialist reader may be convinced of the system’s desirability; however, the question of feasibility remains a dark cloud over the illustrated utopia. Even if he could prove that people would behave in a communal and just manner, how would society be restructured around this behavior (since capitalism is driven by the assumption that human nature is inherently greedy and fearful–completely different values than those of socialism)? Coupled with the anti-socialist resistance from existing capitalist forces, a complete transition to socialism would have to entail a large, mobile socialist revolution. The working class must free themselves from the effect that capitalism has had on their relations, reframing their values to pursue an entirely new form of community. As Socialism comes to an end, Cohen leads his reader to a similar conclusion as Marx does in his Communist Manifesto; workers must utilize organized politics to overthrow the capitalist system, or, as Marx more explicitly proclaims, “Working men of all countries unite!”
Caroline’s Writer Bio
Hometown: Concord, MA.
(Intended) Major: English.
Favorite Author/Book: Giovanni’s Room by James Baldwin.
Preferred Writing Mode: Narrative.
On-campus Writing Spot: Axinn Center.