Can I Be Pretty?

Jack Barnhart

A dive into my own gender identity through the lens of Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home

I lie in bed reading Fun Home by Alison Bechdel. The words wash off the page and over me, a torrid wave with the instant conductivity of scalding water but dry and uncomfortable. Distorted visions of myself force the air from my lungs. I feel the book become heavy in my hands. I set it down, marking my place with a finger and a sigh as I slide to lie flat. I can’t read in this position, but I need some time to think. “Do you have to put a label on yourself?” (211) “keep your options open” “What is really worth it?” (230) These phrases echo in my ears, more than familiar. I’ve never heard them before—actually heard someone say them—but only because I’ve said them to myself first, and followed my own advice.

I crack my window with some effort and stare out into the night. The crickets rebound off of flat concrete as lonely footsteps drown in the rain. I sigh, reminded by the smell of rain on dirt of a similarly rainy day. The unpleasant memory singes my nose as I recall it. He had said “That song lyric feels like it’s about you Jack, you know, from ‘Riptide’ ‘I was scared of pretty girls and starting conversations.’” “You know that one?”   I remember that I had been at a loss for words, but why? Was it the caricature of social incompetence? No, I have accepted that part of myself. Shock that he, a respected friend, would say such a thing? Maybe, but what more could I expect? The connotation of boyish heterosexuality? I sigh, I want to be scared of pretty boys too, and I am, but no amount of dreary weather could cloud my eyes from the fact that, to me, not many boys are pretty. I wonder, absently, at the streetlights that adorn the glistening sidewalks if it is the nature of boys to put each other down with statements like his, if that is what tarnishes our prettiness in my eyes. I remember that, in a poorly disguised attempt to put as much distance between his bitter caricature and myself I had said, with feigned thoughtfulness, staring up into the blank gray sky: “I feel like the second is true of most people and the first is true of anyone who is attracted to women.” I realized then, staring into the night, that in generalizing to anyone I had been attempting to distance the connotations of masculinity from myself. Maybe my yearning to “be afraid of” pretty boys was a similar attempt to generalize my attraction and escape the conventions of my gender.  There is nothing aesthetic, nothing respectable, in my mind, about conventional masculinity, nothing aesthetic about myself at least not from that lens, the lens he just forced upon my perception of myself. Yet there are many boys that I have respected, that are pretty, that I have even been afraid of, but still I wonder, why can’t I have been a girl?

Bruce Allan Bechdel, as portrayed in Fun Home, was the reason I had set down the book, the reason I needed to think. I still can’t help but compare his worldview, and tragedy, to myself. Not that there aren’t countless differences to outweigh these comparisons. He was gay at a time when you had to choose between your sexuality and having “a life” and the complicated, unhappy, and borderline evil man that resulted is, in that sense, nothing like me. However, his aversion to conventional masculinity, justification for not coming out, and obsession with decor are all terrifyingly analogous to my own predicament—right down to the cover art of my edition. The closed book stares up at me with a photo of the Bechdel family without Bruce, no doubt taken by him, each one in a ludicrously formal outfit—forced into an appearance that reinforces his fictional reality, the idealized facade of the family life he chose instead of himself—to escape the terror of coming out. Similarly, I have always preferred fiction to reality, voraciously reading throughout my childhood to escape the inevitable expectations of masculinity. Once the sex scenes invaded my repertoire of fantasy novels I sought out a different escape: wandering in the forest for hours, collecting various plants and fungi and then cooking overly fancy meals with them or, often, without them: cooking perfect meals, every day, and defining myself by their quality. While this is, in many ways, unlike Bruce’s self-destructive artificial life, it was a way of “spinning garbage into gold” through a stereotypically feminine activity and was, in every way, self destructive. Like Bruce, unable to express myself socially, I defined myself by a self-deceiving artifice.

                                                            ~~~

I sit crying atop a hill of rotting apples as cars rush by.

“Why? Why is ‘everyone’ so mean?”

I scream silently so no one overhears, my face still stinging from the asphalt and their jeering laughter. He had smashed into me, shoved me onto the hard pavement for what? To prove he was better? To win whatever game we had been playing?

                                                            ~~~

At my middle school there were two ways of socializing non-romantically: You could play sports (and get hurt and bullied), or be a girl. I remember them hugging when they saw each other each day, talking kindly about anything, understanding. I remember wishing I could have that, have someone to talk to, have anything, anything but this. So I went back to childhood, played with sticks as if they were swords, tried to be the characters I used to read about, tried to forget that I was myself. Choosing, instead, to live, not unlike Alison’s Father, in a fantasy.

Back when I was too young to have anything but genuine friendship my dad brought me to New Mexico. I would play among the red rocks and sand and cacti in a way profoundly different from back home, free to be myself for the first time in my life without the distractions of pointless competition. Simply exploring the world of sand and wind and beauty. Next to the red clay wall where the great cottonwood’s leaves whispered in that wind was where I met the boy with the long blond hair and the pink bow. This was the first and maybe only validation I ever got when I was young that boys can be pretty, that I could be pretty. In elementary school I wanted, desperately, to be pretty, and yet the social measure for my worth, being a boy, was competition and athleticism. It was then that my best friends were tomboys, girls who were striving for the very thing I was trying to escape. Why can’t I have been born a girl? I thought then, maybe more even than now, longing for a world where I could be defying people’s expectation for me to be pretty, instead of the other way around; it looked so easy for them, the opposite seemed impossible for me. Even in the friendliest, most accepting elementary school, my pink rain boots with the little turtles were shunned.

I’d like to pretend we are getting away from this as a society, away from the gendered generalizations. I’d like to say it is nurture not nature that defines any differences due to gender and that biological sex has nothing to do with it. There is data to back me up, studies that conclude “At the beginning of our life, there isn’t any distinct sex difference when it comes to crying… But as children get older… boys receive more parental disapproval when they cry than girls do.” (FEARS) Some even conclude that the norm of masculine inexpressiveness is a culturally ingrained attempt to maintain the gendered social hierarchy through an air of impenetrably mysterious respectability (Williams). These distinctions are held as biases in all of us. Even Bechdel writes “The bar is lower for fathers than for mothers.” (22) remembering more clearly being bathed as a child by her father one time than the many other times by her mother. This expression of kindness, of parental care, is where there is a lower bar. As unfortunate as the lack of appreciation for a mother’s kindness is, the lack of expectation for a father’s kindness is the side of the distinction that haunts me. I can’t imagine that other men and boys could possibly want to live in a world where they can’t be genuine, where kindness is not only unexpected but laughed at. It seems unbearably tragic to forsake kindness and emotion to feel above others. Perhaps most men are drawn to that and I am simply caught in the fray. Everyone, including Bechdel, has a subconscious bias towards respecting male autonomy. After all, most people would, like Bechdel, be more outraged if Alison’s father had pictures of 17 year-old girls rather than boys. But it seems impossible to me that someone would choose this, that these norms could develop at all. Who would want to take responsibility for being taken advantage of? Who would want to go through life without someone to confide in, someone to relate to? If being a man is really about being an emotionless mask that puts others down and is held responsible for everything then how could anyone possibly want to be a man?

Staring out my window into the darkness, a frantic flurry of thoughts flood my brain. I tell myself that I refuse to call myself non-binary because it acknowledges that a binary exists. But now I can’t escape the fact that I am probably just too afraid to be different. That there are people who like the binary and they cannot be at fault for that. It seemed compelling to me that larger, generalized, progress should be made.  Why not forget gender altogether as a society? Why not just let people like who they want to like and be who they want to be? Why not let anyone wear long hair with bows and pink boots and not call them anything based on that? Why not let people define their personality in ways independent of antiquated roles based on their genitalia? The assumptions people make about others based on their perceived gender is sad and horrible and ridiculous. It requires me to hide behind the wall from the boy with the bow and pretend I cannot comprehend emotion, pretend I can only think of the world from the context of brutish and ignorant objectivity. I slide down the wall of my room and curl up onto the floor trying, in vain, to cry.

This is the paradox of my evasion of masculinity—my hatred takes the form of an entitled masculine expression, focused on how my experience should shape others rather than what it means for myself. Deciding that if masculinity doesn’t work for me then it must work for no one. I continue to call myself “he” justifying it, telling myself I am nobly redefining what it means to be male. Words start popping into my head in my fatigued delirium. Better to “keep my options open” right? “Of course, it seems like a cop-out. But then, who are cop outs for? Taking sides is rather heroic, and I am not a hero. What is really worth it?” (230) Am I just justifying the same cop-out that haunted Alison’s father?  How is my denial of gender any different from homophobia? After all, it is based on the same phrases. It seems to me now that I was trying to ascribe heroics to my inaction rather than acknowledge that many people feel happy with their gender and what it entails. Am I uncomfortable with people who identify strongly with a specific gender in the same way that Allison’s mother was uncomfortable with Alison’s homosexuality?  In what world does that extend to any kind of generalization in either case? In what way is my denial of gender any different from someone’s morally reprehensible denial of homosexuality? Then again, I find it hard to believe that anyone wouldn’t feel limited by their gender at least at some point in their life.

I walk the balance between conforming by coming out as different or living my life in defiance of the masculine hierarchy that put the norms in place. Put that way the latter seems heroic but to me it feels like the easy way out. Bechdel alludes to her father’s closeted homosexuality as a life “ruined, undone, wasted, wrecked, and spoiled.” (119) That he realized he would never get what he needed from life, that that was what sent him into the truck. It was my fear of finding myself in his shoes later in life that sent me to the window and then to the floor that night. I know, deep down, that within my lifetime things won’t change. No matter how old I get I will never see the day where I can express emotion without shame unless I call myself something other than a man. It is just so hard to see which one is the cop out before it is too late, before I am living a life of regret. Bechdel describes an aspect of her father’s regret, his loss, through a photo of him in a women’s bathing suit. Perhaps describing the beauty and happiness he could have had. Her first reaction is that it is a prank, a joke at his expense. However, she rules out this option with the somehow exclusive assertion of his elegance, assuming that, in a prank, his pose would be shameful. I wonder, though, would it ever be assumed as shameful for a woman to wear a man’s clothes? Would that ever be a prank? It seems that the assumption that men are better than women makes it shameful for a man to act in any way feminine but not the other way around. This is corroborated by papers that state: the expectation for a man’s expression of emotion is not “the complete rejection of emotion, but is instead constructed as doing emotion in a way that can be defended as ‘not feminine.’” (FEARS) Bechdel describes her father’s elegance as exclusive of a prank because there is some voluntarity to it, a willingness that, she seems to imply, could only come from someone who is gay. One scholar analyzing Bechdel’s work says that “the youthful cross-gender dressing with which she and her father both experiment… [is rooted in] the hopeful possibility that ‘the gender identity that these scenes attempt to inscribe on the body as norms are shrouded in instability’” (Froese). However, I still don’t see the instability of these norms ever transcending implications of sexuality and toppling. It seems, unfortunately, that the patriarchy will continue to hold us all in its emotionless grip and that genders will forever be divided.

Then again, this seems like a brutal rejection of people who define themselves by gender. People who believe gender to be an inherent trait of nature. As one trans-woman writes: “I have always been a woman, but my womanhood was ignored and even denied by my life circumstances… I call this ‘closeted womanhood,’… I never had a male experience” (Malmrose 1–2). Gender is an aspect of many people’s identities that helps them just as much as it hurts me. As ridiculous as the idea of a “male” or “female” experience is to my mind, the distinction is relevant and meaningful to others. I keep treating the existence of any and all distinctions as the problem rather than the specifically problematic distinctions themselves. In the end, gendered differences aren’t the problem for me. The problem is the way masculinity is narrowly defined as an identity devoid of prettiness and emotion. Therefore, the best I can do is to redefine what masculinity can and should look like for me by defying these expectations, the ones rooted in the preservation of inequality. I will continue to be conscious of, and push away, the hesitancy that divides me from myself and strive to accept my emotion with open arms.  Hopefully, in the future, this rejection of the norms placed on me will help create a world where boys can hug each other and wear pink boots without any shame. Before that can happen, though, I need to accept my own emotions and embody the prettiness that I know I can have.

Works cited

“FEARS FOR TEARS; For men and boys, the pressure to not show emotion in public is crushing, even in supposedly progressive circles – and it hurts everyone. Rachel Giese asks how we can make room for male vulnerability.” Globe & Mail [Toronto, Canada], 7 July 2018, p. O1. Gale General OneFile, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A545667542/ITOF ?u=vol_m58c&sid=bookmark-ITOF&xid=69bea3bc. Accessed 3 May 2022.

Froese, Jocelyn Sakal. “Lateral Moves and Ghostly Gay Children: Queer Spatial Metaphors in Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home.” Inks: The Journal of the Comics Studies Society, vol. 4 no. 3, 2020, p. 251-265. Project MUSE, doi:10.1353/ink.2020.0020.

Malmrose, Ellie. “Closeted Womanhood.” Contexts, vol. 16, no. 4, 2017, pp. 82–83, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26370603. Accessed 3 May 2022.

Williams, Dorie Giles. 1985. Gender, masculinity – femininity, and emotional intimacy in same-sex friendship. Sex Roles 12, no. 5: 587, http://ezproxy.middlebury.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/gender-masculinity-femininity-emotional-intimacy/docview/1308098826/se-2.

Bibliography

Parga Linares, Santiago. “Proustian Curiosity and the Archive: Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home.” Journal of Graphic Novels & Comics, vol. 12, no. 5, Oct. 2021, pp. 780–96. EBSCOhost, discovery.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=27d20dfd-fdca-30bd-a5f0-b65569c3cffd.

Sadri, Houman. “The Return Journey in Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home.” Journal of Popular Culture, vol. 53, no. 1, Feb. 2020, pp. 111–28. EBSCOhost, discovery.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=238ade48-9402-333b-bab4-f7f5dac81805.

Spiers, Miriam Brown. “Daddy’s Little Girl: Multigenerational Queer Relationships in Bechdel’s Fun Home.” Studies in Comics, vol. 1, no. 2, Aug. 2010, pp. 315–35. EBSCOhost, discovery.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=8440a172-ed43-395b-8443-a47524982a82.

Poirier, Fanny. “Applications of Knowledge and Plural Realities: Understanding Gender Identity through Non-Binary Genders.” Recherches En Psychanalyse, vol. 29, Jan. 2020, pp. 39–46. EBSCOhost, discovery.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=3a69c099-aaa9-3e3c-9211-0a08fd212087.

Michael, Olga. “Queering the Family, Reclaiming the Father: Proustian Evocations in Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home.” Biography, vol. 43 no. 2, 2020, p. 430-457. Project MUSE, doi:10.1353/bio.2020.0036.

“A TRUE HERO; First he came out as gay, now he’s gone public on living with HIV. Wales rugby legend Gareth Thomas is …MARTIN SAMUEL Chief Sports Writer COMMENT.” Daily Mail [London, England], 16 Sept. 2019, p. 80. Gale In Context: Biography, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A599653206/BIC?u=vol_m58c&sid=bookmark-BIC&xid=57b4d8c0. Accessed 3 May 2022.

Froese, Jocelyn Sakal. “Lateral Moves and Ghostly Gay Children: Queer Spatial Metaphors in Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home.” Inks: The Journal of the Comics Studies Society, vol. 4 no. 3, 2020, p. 251-265. Project MUSE, doi:10.1353/ink.2020.0020.

Butler, Donald. “Grayson Perry and the Recalibration of Masculine Emotional Reactions to Vulnerability and Healing.” The Journal of Analytical Psychology, vol. 65, no. 2, Apr. 2020, pp. 444–63. EBSCOhost, discovery.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=ded62172-2066-31f7-aafd-7e6821032a91.

Paechter, Carrie, et al. “Non-Binary Young People and Schools: Pedagogical Insights from a Small-Scale Interview Study.” Pedagogy, Culture and Society, vol. 29, no. 5, Jan. 2021, pp. 695–713. EBSCOhost, discovery.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=4c8c645d-6b1d-3cf6-89aa-30dbca85cc87.

Williams, Dorie Giles. 1985. Gender, masculinity – femininity, and emotional intimacy in same-sex friendship. Sex Roles 12, no. 5: 587, http://ezproxy.middlebury.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/gender-masculinity-femininity-emotional-intimacy/docview/1308098826/se-2.  BECHDEL, ALISON, and Hillary Chute. “AN INTERVIEW WITH ALISON BECHDEL.” Modern Fiction Studies, vol. 52, no. 4, 2006, pp. 1004–13,

“Lesbian Cartoonist Alison Bechdel Countered Dad’s Secrecy By Being Out And Open.” Fresh Air, 17 Aug. 2015, p. NA. Gale Literature Resource Center, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A425971426/LitRC?u=vol_m58c&sid=ebsco&xid=1f3b86f1. Accessed 3 May 2022.

malmrose, ellie. “Closeted Womanhood.” Contexts, vol. 16, no. 4, 2017, pp. 82–83, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26370603. Accessed 3 May 2022.

Cherry, Joanna. “Why I was sacked, coming out as gay during the Aids pandemic, and turmoil in the SNP.” New Statesman, vol. 150, no. 5606, 12 Feb. 2021, p. 9. Gale Academic OneFile Select, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A653365225/EAIM?u=vol_m58c&sid=bookmark-EAIM&xid=3e6e4c91. Accessed 3 May 2022.

Jack’s Writer Bio

Hometown: Barnard, Vermont.

Favorite Author: Emily Dickinson.

Preferred Writing Modes: Poetry/Fiction.

On-campus Writing Spots: Starr library or anywhere outside.

Best Writing Feedback Received: Writing is just as much a tool for discovery as it is a medium for expression. Never try to perfect every sentence in your first draft and always be open to changing your plan.

Advice for Fellow Writers: Always be engaged with your writing. If you aren’t enjoying the writing process you shouldn’t be writing that piece. You might be expressing something difficult but that doesn’t mean writing should be a chore. It is never to late to change everything and write about something different or write it in a different way.

License

Share This Book