The Prince: a Deadly Trap
Jack Barnhart
Niccolo Machiavelli dedicated his work describing how to keep and hold power as a prince to Lorenzo de’ Medici. It seems odd that, having been tortured by the Medici, Machiavelli would be interested in giving Lorenzo good-hearted advice. As he says himself: “Men should either be caressed or eliminated, because they avenge themselves for slight offenses but cannot do so for grave ones.” (Machiavelli 10) Being tortured is not a grave offence but certainly warrants revenge, so, by his own logic, Macheavelli might have written and dedicated “The Prince” with the goal to avenge himself. One explanation under this lens is that Machiavelli wrote “The Prince” in jest—to poke fun at the Medici for lacking any semblance of morals. He does, after all, advise “inhuman cruelty,” (Machiavelli 67) perhaps amusing himself with the notion that anyone would take such a suggestion seriously. However, this seems unlikely given that the scope of the work applies well beyond the Medici: In chapter fifteen Machiavelli reveals his intent to “write something useful to whoever understands it.” (Machiavelli 61) He may, therefore, instead be satirizing “whoever understands it”—princes in general—but this seems equally unlikely due to his wishes that they find it useful. Said wish may be sarcastic as well but his points seem far too intricate and precise for the whole work to be a joke. It is more likely, in my mind, that Macheavelli wrote “The Prince” as a trap for the Medici—to get people to hate them. Because of this, much of what he says seems entirely logical from the standpoint of anyone looking to acquire power but illogical from the standpoint of garnering a positive public image.
Machiavelli stresses at many points that a Prince must avoid being hated by his people; however, there are several instances where he contradicts his own advice. One of his most interesting suggestions is that a ruler should choose to be feared rather than loved in order to avoid being overthrown. However, when talking about the French parliament, he says: “the hatred of the generality of people against the great… is founded in its fear.” (Machiavelli 75) If hatred is to be avoided and hatred comes from fear then why should it be logical to prefer to be feared? This contradiction most likely arises from Machiavelli’s deceptive intent with “The Prince;” he wants to simultaneously stay as close to the truth as possible while offering dubious advice that will lead to the downfall of Lorenzo De’ Medici. Therefore, he offers sound logic but inadvisable conclusions—his statement concerning fear’s relationship with hatred is accurate in the example of the French parliament because it is logic that leads to his conclusion rather than a conclusion itself.
This contradiction is not nearly as simple as I portray it. There are multiple other relevant dimensions to the issue; however, despite the layers of complexity, the above conclusion stands. It is pertinent to note that Machiavelli, in the original Italian, uses two distinct words for fear in these separate situations (Fram). The first, where Machiavelli advises being feared over being loved, is translated from the Italian “Temere,” while the second, where he states that hatred arises from fear, was originally “Paura.” Machiavelli uses “Paura” to describe terrorizing people suddenly and without warning in a way that breeds hatred. His use of “temere,” on the other hand, implies institutionalizing a dread of retribution that enforces respect. The key distinction here is that Machiavelli is advising a fear-based tyrannical rule, by the prince, over the great—those who might look to overthrow him—while warning against sporadically terrorizing the common folk. The french parliament are “the great” and routinely terrorize the common folk to no benefit for themselves (Fram). This brings us back to the matter of people avenging themselves for slight offenses—Machiavelli is encouraging the prince to crush the great; there is no returning from a “grave offense”. However, despite this, fear is fear—no matter how helpless the great are made to feel, they are no different from the common folk in their opinion of the source of that fear. Machiavelli is capitalizing on the greed of Lorenzo de’ Medici to follow him deep within his twisted web of logic. He emphasizes the power of a reign of terror, knowing that Medici will be unable to resist. Enticing him with contradictory logic by spinning threads that are harmless and believable on their own but come together to form a deadly trap.
This, however, is a mere sliver of Machiavelli’s ill intentioned conclusions. Additional malicious advice of Machiavelli’s includes: committing grave offenses against your people (Machiavelli 10), doing many bad things at once (Machiavelli 38), decreasing the fortifications of your homes (Machiavelli 86), letting the people have weapons (Machiavelli 83), nourishing enmity (Machiavelli 85), and to engage in the aforementioned inhuman cruelty (Machiavelli 67). Machiavelli delivers these suggestions with such clever logic that today most people believe he meant them in earnest. I would argue that Machiavelli has every reason to harm Lorenzo de’ Medici, not the least of which being jealousy, and it would be illogical to conclude that he intended to give good-hearted advice to his enemy.
Machiavelli emphasizes that jealousy is a defining trait of the conspirator (Machiavelli 75). Jealousy, however, is a key theme in both Machiavelli’s dedicatory letter for “The Prince” and his 1513 letter to Francesco Vettori. Once again, this is macheavelli’s attempt to remain as truthful as possible to avoid suspicion. In the dedication, fortune is the only “quality” of Lorenzo de’ Medici’s that Machiavelli bothers to name: “fortune and your other qualities,” (Machiavelli 4) implying that Machiavelli does not actually respect Lorenzo in the least. He then refers to his own situation as a “malignity of fortune” (Machiavelli 4) hinting at how undeserving he is of his lack of political position. Here Machiavelli essentially states that he is smarter than Lorenzo de’ Medici and would hold much greater power if not for his horrible luck. This comparison is laced with jealousy, a trait that, as I have noted, Macheavelli himself associates with the conspirator. Additionally, in his letter to Vettori he indignantly describes the minutiae of how utterly pointless his life is because he is not engaged in politics. This further cements the great level to which jealousy shapes his thoughts and motivations, an undeniable source of resentment towards the Medici family and the mark of a conspirator.
Machiavelli, when describing a day in his tragically non-political life, made note of the fact that he “enters the ancient courts of ancient men.” (Machiavelli 109) If he spent so much time studying Plato and Aristotle he must have noted the distinction between tyranny and kingship that they make that condemns tyranny beyond all else. Therefore, it is puzzling that he neglects to make that distinction clear in “The Prince.” This is because, while Plato, for example, viewed politics as a tool to promote the good, Machiavelli’s “The Prince,” looks at politics simply as a manifestation of the human urge for power over others. He looks at principalities from the end of optimizing the prince’s benefit especially in terms of maintaining wealth and power generally through the means of violence. This, however, is quite consistent with Plato’s definition of tyranny—which he argues is as torturous for the tyrant as it is for the people. It seems to me unlikely that Machiavelli wrote “The Prince” to advise the family that tortured him on how to rise to unedning tyrannical power, at least not one beneficial for them. Instead, it would be more logical to conclude that his motive was to manipulate their greed to lock them in an unhealthy and torturous regime that would end with their deaths at the hands of their own people.
Sources
Daniel Fram, (Written, Canvas, 6 April 2022).
Machiavelli, Niccolo. The Prince., Mansfield, Harvey C., The University of Chicago Press, 1985.