A Shift in Disability Studies: The Social Model of Disability

Anna LeClerc

There have been several models presented within the disabled community, and broader society, to ‘explain’ disability. The most common tradition—the medical model—focuses on the impairments of a disabled individual (Ward 15). Alternatively, the social model of disability, which emerged in the 1970s, describes disability in a different light (Adams 54). The conventional perspective, that the individual with a disability must change to fit into society, shifts so the burden is placed on society to accommodate the needs of those with disabilities. The emergence of the social model created a shift in disability studies.

Initially established in 1976 by the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation (UPIAS) in “The Fundamental Principles of Disability,” the social model clearly defines the difference between ‘disability’ and ‘impairment’ (Jordan). The social model views ‘impairment’ as the anatomical difference in a disabled person and defines ‘disability’ as the societal construct that imposes obstacles on disabled individuals (Ward 16). ‘Disability’ consequently inhibits a disabled individual’s engagement in their community (Adams 107). This may include unwelcoming schools and workplaces, insufficient disability benefits and services, poor building design, and the inaccurate portrayal of disabled people in mass media (Cologon 21). Thus, the social model concludes that the main struggles disabled people face come from external, societal factors (Jordan). Simi Linton describes the social model using the analogy of a fist: one open hand represents society and the other hand, in a fist, represents disabled people (Linton 518). We, as a society, typically think of the fist needing to find a way to fit perfectly into the open hand. However, the social model focuses on the idea that the fist may not fit because of the open hand’s stiff shape and shortcomings (Linton 518). The social model can be liberating for people with disabilities because they no longer have to feel that it is their fault they do not ‘fit in’ with society.

Two noted disability scholars believe in two discrete schools of thought regarding the social model of disability. Mike Oliver is a scholar who largely bases his work on the UPIAS’ “The Fundamental Principles of Disability” (Adams 54). Oliver asserts that disability only exists when society imposes obstacles on people. He further claims that doctors, academics, and society, as a whole, often see ‘impairment’ as more accurate and scientific than ‘disability’ (Adams 108). Oliver views the social model as the superior view of disability.

Tom Shakespeare, a British scholar and activist, critiques the social model. He sees it as restricted and erroneous. Shakespeare asserts that the social model does not take into consideration the physical ailments and disadvantages disabled people encounter, thus discounting the disabled experience as a whole. Further, he argues the social model causes an irrational distrust of medical advancements that could ultimately help those with disabilities (Adams 107). Shakespeare believes the disabled community needs more than just equality in society; they need equity (Adams 107). The views of Oliver and Shakespeare begin to uncover the varying degrees to which the field of academia accepts the social model of disability.

Despite its criticism, the social model of disability shifted the perspective from emphasizing the disabled person to a less constrictive perspective of emphasizing societal obstacles. For example, the social model encourages more disability equality training and sparked a political movement organized by people with disabilities (Jordan). Therefore, while a model that acknowledges both the external and internal effects of impairment and disability on disabled people seems preferable, the social model clearly ignited a shift in perspective within disability studies.

Works Cited

Cologon, Kathy. “‘What Is Disability? It Depends Whose Shoes You Are Wearing’: Parent Understandings of the Concept of Disability.” Disability Studies Quarterly, vol. 36, no. 1, 2016, https://doi.org/10.18061/dsq.v36i1.4448.

Keywords for Disability Studies, edited by Rachel Adams, et al., New York University Press, 2015. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/middlebury/detail.action?docID=3564341.

Lesley Jordan, and Wendy Kaiser. Aphasia — A Social Approach. Springer, 2013. EBSCOhost, discovery.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=619e729f-a1e6-3696-ab13-076c3b04774c.

Linton, Simi. “What Is Disability Studies?” PMLA, vol. 120, no. 2, Modern Language Association, 2005, pp. 518–22, http://www.jstor.org/stable/25486177.

Ridolfo, Heather, and Brian W. Ward. “2: Building on Models of Disability.” Mobility Impairment and the Construction of Identity, 2013, pp. 15–17. Alexander Street, Lynne Rienner Publishers.

Anna’s Writer Bio

Hometown: Northborough, Massachusetts.

(Intended) Major: Neuroscience.

Favorite Author/Book: The Glass Castle by Jeanette Walls.

Preferred Writing Modes: Personal reflective or journalistic articles.

On-campus Writing Spot: Axinn Center by the windows.

Best Writing Feedback Received: The best writing feedback I have received is that you can never be finished editing your work. Also, it is often more important for your work to be clear and concise than to use excessive vocabulary.

Advice for Fellow Writers: Middlebury’s writing resources have been very helpful to me so far including the peer writing tutors at the Writing Center and office hours with professors.

License

Share This Book